
analyze data from a 2-week sample monitor test and decide, criterion by criterion, how well our monitor measures and shrinks an impact.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Before you see the results, predict: which impact will our action cut by at least 10%, and which will barely change? Write your prediction and one reason.
Our action was a share table for unopened food plus a “take only what you'll eat” poster. Which impact should drop most?
Test week results are in. For two weeks, teams ran the version 2 monitor. Week 1 was the baseline. In week 2, the school tried the share table and poster. Here is the class data set. All numbers are sample data; your class will use its own.
| Measure (sample data) | Week 1 (baseline) | Week 2 (action) | Change | Percent change |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Water used (L) | 18,000 | 17,400 | −600 | |
| Food waste (kg) | 22.0 | 18.7 | −3.3 | |
| Trash (kg) | 41.0 | 38.5 | −2.5 | |
| Routine time (min) | 8 | 9 | — | |
| School days / students | 5 / 600 | 5 / 600 | — |
Our class criteria, from 4.09. The impact monitor must:
Worked example 1: the 10% criterion. Food waste: 3.3 ÷ 22.0 × 100 = 15%. That meets “at least 10%.” Water: 600 ÷ 18,000 × 100 ≈ 3.3%. Trash: 2.5 ÷ 41.0 × 100 ≈ 6.1%. Only one action needs to cut one impact by 10%, so the criterion is met by food waste.
Worked example 2: fair-test check. Ethan asks, “Could something else explain the food-waste drop?” Both weeks had 5 days and 600 students, so per-day and per-student comparisons give the same result. But week 2’s menu might have been more popular. “A 2-week test shows a promising result, not proof. Repeating it would make the claim stronger.”
Every criterion, honestly. Time was 8 and 9 minutes, under 10 both weeks. Cost was $120 against the $150 sample budget. Biodiversity: the native strip is planted, but two weeks is too short to count new species, so this criterion is “met in plan, not yet in data.”
Complete the percent-change column first, then answer.
Write the test report.
Make a criteria scorecard: for each of the five criteria, write the data and mark met, not met or met in plan. Then write a claim about how well the monitor works.
Name two limits of the 2-week test or the monitor's tools, and one change you would make before the school runs it all semester.
You now have honest test data. Next class you present it to the green team and the watershed group.
Exit ticket: write one sentence a green-team member should hear about the test, including a number and a limit.
How confident are you that you can I can analyze test data to decide how well a design meets its criteria.
Materials: the class’s real 2-week log (or the sample set above), calculators, graph paper or a spreadsheet, the criteria poster.
Setup: the monitor test runs during the two weeks before this lesson, with daily or Friday data collection by rotating student teams. If your test is not finished, use the sample data and analyze the real data later. Replace the $150 sample budget with your class’s number.
Listen for: calling 6% a pass; “the test proves” language; ignoring the biodiversity criterion.
Support / stretch: pre-fill the formula for one row. Stretch: calculate food waste per student per day in both weeks.