
use data to find the best feature of each competing design and combine them into one monitor that better meets our criteria.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. A pizza place asks three cooks for their best pizza. One has the best crust, one the best sauce, one the best toppings. What should the owner do? How is that like our three monitors?
Engineers often combine the strongest features of several designs instead of choosing only one.
From three designs to one. No single trial design met every criterion. Our job today is to look feature by feature and ask: which part of each design gave the best data?
Our class criteria, from 4.09. The impact monitor must:
Step 1: break each design into features. Design A has a weekly water-meter reading (2 minutes) and runoff cups (10 minutes to set up, empty and measure). Design B has a Friday weigh-in of three bins (8 minutes). Design C has a quick lights walk-through (6 minutes).
Step 2: score features with a weighted decision matrix. Each criterion gets a weight: how much it matters to the clients. Each feature gets a score from 0 to 3. Multiply and add.
| Feature (sample data) | Weekly impact data (weight 3) | Time (weight 2) | Cost (weight 2) | Weighted total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Water-meter reading | 3 | 3 | 3 | 21 |
| Runoff cups | 3 | 1 | 1 | 13 |
| Friday bin weigh-in | 3 | 2 | 2 | 17 |
| Lights walk-through | 2 | 2 | 3 | 16 |
Worked example 1: computing a total. Water-meter reading: (3 × 3) + (3 × 2) + (3 × 2) = 9 + 6 + 6 = 21. Runoff cups: (3 × 3) + (1 × 2) + (1 × 2) = 9 + 2 + 2 = 13. The meter reading is fast, free and measures a real impact every week.
Worked example 2: building the hybrid. Jamal’s team keeps the two highest scorers, the meter reading and the bin weigh-in. Time: 2 + 8 = 10 minutes, which is not under 10. So they trim the weigh-in to two bins, trash and food waste, which they timed at 6 minutes (sample). New total: 2 + 6 = 8 minutes. Cost: $0 + $60 = $60, under the $150 sample budget. Runoff moves to the biodiversity add-on, where a rain garden can measure and reduce it at once.
Claim with evidence. “The hybrid meets the time, cost and two-impact criteria better than any single design, because it keeps the highest-scoring features (21 and 17 points) and drops the slowest one (runoff cups, 13 points).”
Use the decision matrix above. Show your math in your notebook.
Build your own team’s hybrid.
Make a decision matrix for your team's features with your own weights. Explain why you chose each weight, using what the green team and watershed group need.
Write a claim: which features will you combine, and why? Cite at least two numbers from your matrix or trial data, and name one trade-off you accepted.
You now have a hybrid plan. Next class, you will see how ordinary people monitor real streams and air.
Exit ticket: name one feature you combined and the data that convinced you it was the best of its kind.
How confident are you that you can I can use data to combine the best features of several designs.
Materials: decision-matrix template, calculators, the 4.15 trial table, sticky notes for weights.
Setup: let teams choose their own weights, then compare how weights change the winner. Keep the class criteria fixed; only the weights vary.
Listen for: “highest score means perfect” (it still must pass every criterion); forgetting to multiply by weights; dropping runoff entirely.
Support / stretch: provide a partly filled matrix. Stretch: test how sensitive the result is by changing one weight from 2 to 3 and recomputing.