
organize trial data from three competing impact-monitor designs in a table and explain how each one tracks a real human impact.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Think about one ordinary school day. List three things our school uses up or throws away, and guess where each one goes after it leaves the building.
Rain runs off our parking lot and roof into a storm drain. Where does that water most likely end up?
Monitor builders, welcome to the Build phase. In Make Sense you explained how more people and more use per person put pressure on water, land and living things. Now you turn that science into a tool for two clients: the school’s green team and a local watershed group.
Restate the problem. Our school uses water, makes waste and sends runoff toward the creek. Nobody measures these impacts week by week, so nobody knows whether changes help. The clients need a simple monitor that measures the footprint and proves that one action shrinks it.
Our class criteria, from 4.09. The impact monitor must:
Why measure at all? A human activity causes an effect on Earth’s systems. Paved surfaces stop rain from soaking in, so more water rushes off, carrying oil, soil and litter into the creek. Food waste in a landfill breaks down and releases methane, a greenhouse gas. You cannot shrink an impact you never measure.
Three competing designs. Last week three teams tried a monitor for one week. Their trial results are below. All numbers are sample data.
| Design | Impacts measured weekly | Minutes a week | Cost | Supports biodiversity? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A: Water and Runoff Watch (meter reading, rain gauge, runoff cups at a downspout) | 2 (water use, runoff) | 12 | $175 | Not yet |
| B: Waste Watch (weigh trash, recycling and food waste every Friday) | 2 (trash, food waste) | 8 | $60 | Not yet |
| C: Lights and Plugs Watch (walk-through count of lights left on; monthly electric bill) | 1 (lights left on) | 6 | $0 | Not yet |
Worked example 1: reading the table against the criteria. Priya checks Design C first. It is fast and free, but the electric bill comes monthly, so only one impact is measured weekly. “Design C fails the ‘at least 2 impacts weekly’ criterion, even though it wins on time and cost.”
Worked example 2: cause and effect, or just a pattern? Diego notices that runoff was highest on the week trash was lowest. He asks, “Did less trash cause more runoff?” No: that week had the most rain, and rain causes runoff. Two numbers changing together is a correlation. A cause needs a reason grounded in science.
Work with your team. Use the trial table above for every block.
Organize the evidence in your notebook.
Copy the trial table and add a column for each of our five criteria. Mark each cell met, not met or not yet tested. Which design meets the most criteria?
Pick one design. Explain in 3–4 sentences how the human activity it measures causes a negative effect on Earth's water, land or air. Use the words “cause” and “effect.”
Good start, monitor builders. Next class you will combine the best features of all three designs instead of picking one winner.
Exit ticket: name one feature from a design that FAILED a criterion that is still worth keeping. Explain why.
How confident are you that you can I can organize test data from three designs and compare them with the criteria.
Materials: the class criteria poster from 4.09, notebooks, graph paper, the trial table on a slide, gloves and a bathroom scale to show Design B’s tools.
Setup: the trial table is sample data. If your teams ran real one-week trials in Part 1, use those numbers. Replace the $150 sample budget with the number your class set in 4.09.
Listen for: “the cheapest design wins” (every criterion counts); confusing correlation with cause; “runoff goes to a treatment plant” (most storm drains do not).
Support / stretch: give a criteria checklist with check boxes. Stretch: propose a fourth design that measures habitat loss, such as mowed area versus planted area.