
give and use peer feedback to evaluate each station against the criteria, and revise the exhibit into version 2.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Think of a time someone gave you feedback that actually helped. What made it helpful instead of hurtful?
Which comment is the most useful feedback for a station?
Designers, today other teams become your first visitors. We use a protocol called I Like, I Wonder, What If. “I like” names a strength tied to a criterion. “I wonder” asks a question about a weakness. “What if” suggests one change. Be kind, specific and helpful.
The rotation. Each team leaves one Explainer at its exhibit. Everyone else rotates in 6-minute rounds. Critics complete the station, time it, try to explain one piece of evidence, and score it against the five criteria, from 1 to 4.
Worked example 1: turning critique into a decision. Priya’s limbs station got three notes: “I like the colored bones; matching is fast.” “I wonder why the whale fossil has no audio.” “What if the bones were also textured, so touch alone can match them?” Her team scored two fixes in a mini matrix: textured bones (helps accessibility, costs little) beat a second speaker (helps, but over budget). Evidence chose the fix.
Worked example 2: a revision claim. Jamal wrote: “Version 2 of the ecosystems station adds printed step cards and a vibration buzzer when frogs drop. Now a no-hearing visitor gets the information through sight and touch. Our retest time fell from 4 minutes to 2 minutes 30 seconds (sample data).” Claim, change, evidence.
Use these while you critique and revise.
Build and justify version 2.
Make the top two revisions. Then write a revision claim: what changed, which criterion it helps, and what evidence shows it worked (a quick retest time or explanation).
Update your sample budget. Is version 2 still within the sample materials budget? Show the math.
Version 2 is ready, designers. Next: Visitor Test Day, where ten visitors decide whether we met the criteria.
Exit ticket: which piece of feedback changed your exhibit the most, and why was it the right one to act on?
How confident are you that you can I can use evidence and reasoning to claim which solution works best.
Materials: critique cards (I Like / I Wonder / What If plus a 1–4 score for each criterion), timers, building supplies, the sample budget sheet.
Setup: model one kind and one unkind comment first. Three 6-minute rotations, then 20 minutes to revise. Keep sensory-test tables from 3.22 at each station.
Listen for: vague praise; teams rejecting all feedback; fixes that break the budget.
Support / stretch: give sentence stems on each card. Stretch: run a two-row matrix to choose between fixes and present it.