
build version 2 of my impact monitor, retest it with the data-log model, and describe how well it now meets the criteria and its remaining limits.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Reread the most useful critique note your team received. Write the one change you will make today and the criterion it should improve.
Engineers should change many parts at once so the redesign goes faster.
Version 2 day. You will build the real monitor kit, rehearse the weekly routine with a stopwatch, and run your revised data-log model on a full set of sample weeks.
The version 2 kit. A clipboard log or spreadsheet, a bathroom scale and gloves for the bins, the meter-reading route, a planting plan for the add-on, and a sign for the action you will test, such as a share table or a “take only what you’ll eat” poster.
Worked example 1: timing the routine. Sample data. Version 1 routine: meter 2 min + weigh-in 6 min + add-on check 2 min = 10 minutes, which fails “under 10.” Version 2 uses a two-person weigh-in: 2 + 4 + 2 = 8 minutes. Three timed rehearsals gave 8, 9 and 8 minutes. The routine now meets the time criterion with a small margin.
Worked example 2: costing the kit. Sample prices: scale $30 (or borrowed from the nurse, $0), gloves $10, native seed mix and plugs $80, signs $30. Total: $150 with a new scale, or $120 with a borrowed one. Against the $150 sample budget, only the borrowed-scale version is under the budget.
Describe how well it works, honestly. Lena’s team writes: “Version 2 measures water use and food waste weekly, takes about 8 minutes, and costs $120. It supports biodiversity with a native strip. It cannot measure runoff yet, and the scale only reads to 0.1 kg, so very small changes may be missed.” That last sentence names the technology’s limits.
| Criterion | Version 1 result | Change made | Version 2 result | Met? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 impacts weekly | ||||
| Action cuts ≥10% | ||||
| Under 10 min/week | ||||
| Under sample budget | ||||
| Supports biodiversity |
Build, time and retest. All numbers are sample data.
Complete the version 2 report.
Fill in the version 1 vs version 2 table. For each criterion, give the data and say whether it is met.
Describe how well version 2 monitors and reduces a human impact, and name two limits of its tools or model. What would version 3 change?
Version 2 is ready for the real test. Next: Prove It, starting with a 2-week sample test against every criterion.
Exit ticket: which criterion is your version 2 most likely to fail in the 2-week test, and why?
How confident are you that you can I can describe how well my solution meets the criteria and name the limits of its technology.
Materials: bathroom scales (borrow if possible), gloves, stopwatches, clipboards, native seed mix or plugs if planting is approved, sign-making supplies.
Setup: prices and times are sample data; replace them with real prices and your class’s budget. Coordinate with cafeteria and facilities staff before the 2-week test begins next class.
Listen for: reporting only the best trial; “equal to the budget counts”; versions that change everything at once.
Support / stretch: give a pre-filled kit cost sheet. Stretch: interview a staff member who manages the building’s utilities and add one of their ideas to version 3.