
define measurable criteria and realistic constraints for the museum exhibit that reflect visitors’ needs, the science and the environment.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Read two messages. The museum educator writes: “School groups move fast, and we serve visitors who are blind or Deaf.” The exhibit manager writes: “We have a small materials budget, and every touch surface must be wiped down daily.” Underline every need you could measure or check.
Which of these is a constraint rather than a criterion?
Explore first. In teams, sort the needs from 3.02 and today’s messages onto two charts: Criteria (what the exhibit must achieve) and Constraints (the limits it must respect). For each, write how we would measure or check it.
| Need | Criterion or constraint? | How we will measure or check it | Target |
|---|---|---|---|
| Visitors use more than their eyes | |||
| Stations are quick | |||
| Visitors understand the evidence | |||
| Works for visitors who cannot see or cannot hear | |||
| Fits the budget | |||
| Survives daily cleaning | |||
| Science is accurate | |||
| Little waste when the exhibit closes |
Name the ideas. Criteria are the requirements a successful design must meet, stated so we can test them. Constraints are limits: time, materials, cost, safety, and effects on people and the environment. Our senses lab matters here: a station that reaches more than one kind of receptor gives more visitors a way in.
Our class criteria. After the sort, the class agreed on these five. Every team designs and tests against them.
Our class constraints. Use only the sample materials budget ($120 per team, sample figure) and the build periods. Fit each station on one table, reachable from a seated height. Use casts, models and pictures, never real fossils or animal parts. Every touch surface must survive wiping. Every claim must match evidence from our investigations. Prefer reusable or recyclable materials.
Worked example 1: vague to precise. “Visitors should learn something” is vague. “At least 8 of 10 test visitors can explain one piece of evidence afterward” names a number, a group and an action we can check in a test.
Worked example 2: a constraint with reasons. Priya wrote, “No paper flaps at touch stations.” Her reasons: paper tears, cannot be wiped clean, and gets thrown away. She suggested laminated cards or plastic instead.
Thinking beyond the visitor. If the exhibit is not built, visitors lose a chance to explore the evidence. If it is built carelessly, it makes waste. Good constraints weigh both.
Use your sorting charts and the class criteria.
Write your team’s design brief.
Copy the five class criteria. Next to each, write how your team will measure it during a test with visitors.
Choose two constraints. Explain the reason for each, and describe one way a careless exhibit could harm the environment or exclude visitors.
We have a clear, testable problem. Next phase, we make sense of our evidence with models and arguments, then brainstorm stations.
Exit ticket: restate the exhibit problem in one sentence. Then name the criterion you think will be hardest to meet, and why.
Materials: educator and manager message cards, sticky notes in two colors, chart paper labeled Criteria and Constraints, the system maps from 3.02.
Setup: let the sort run first, then post the five class criteria exactly as written; part 2 tests every station against them. The sample materials budget is $120 per team, the same figure part 2 uses. The budget item is listed with the criteria because it is checked at the final test, but it also works as a constraint; discuss that overlap.
Listen for: criteria with no way to measure them, and accessibility treated as an add-on. Use respectful language: Deaf, blind, low vision, hard of hearing.
Support / stretch: provide the frame “The station must ___ , which we will check by ___.” Stretch: propose a sixth criterion with a measurable target and defend it to the class.