
give and use evidence-based feedback to find the best features across teams’ monitors and plan specific improvements.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Think of feedback that actually helped you, in a sport, art or homework. What made it useful? Write one rule for giving helpful feedback.
Which is the most useful feedback on a monitor design?
Gallery critique. Each team posts its monitor plan: the data-log model, the biodiversity add-on, the time and cost totals, and a criteria checklist. Teams rotate and leave sticky notes using three stems.
Our class criteria, from 4.09. The impact monitor must:
Worked example 1: a strong critique. Noah writes on Team Heron’s plan: “I like that you normalize runoff per cm of rain, so rainy weeks are fair. I wonder whether your 8-minute routine plus the rain-garden check is still under 10 minutes. What if you use Team Fern’s two-person weigh-in to save 2 minutes?”
Worked example 2: turning feedback into a plan. Team Heron sorts its notes. Sample data: 9 notes about time, 4 about cost, 2 about the add-on. The pattern shows time is their weakest criterion. They plan one change: borrow the two-person weigh-in (6 minutes down to 4, sample timing), bringing the total to 4 + 2 + 2 = 8 minutes with the native strip.
Feedback rules. Critique the design, never the person. Point to a criterion or a number. Every “I wonder” should be something a test could answer.
| Team visited | I like (feature + evidence) | I wonder (data or limit) | What if (change) |
|---|---|---|---|
Practice the protocol before the gallery walk.
Gallery walk, then plan.
After the gallery walk, sort the notes your team received. Which criterion got the most comments? Write the pattern.
Name one feature from another team you will borrow. Explain, with data, why it is better than your current feature and how it changes your model's outputs.
Strong critique makes strong designs. Next class you build and retest version 2.
Exit ticket: write the single most useful note your team received and the change you will make because of it.
How confident are you that you can I can use data and feedback to combine the best features of different designs.
Materials: team posters, three colors of sticky notes (one per stem), timer, feedback-sorting sheet.
Setup: 4-minute rotations; each student leaves at least one note of each color per poster. Model one critique live first. Team names and numbers in examples are sample data.
Listen for: vague praise; notes about people instead of designs; teams that defend instead of listening.
Support / stretch: provide sentence frames on the sticky notes. Stretch: act as a “client voice,” critiquing only from the green team’s or the watershed group’s point of view.