
test the exhibit with ten visitors, compare the data with every class criterion, and decide on one final fix.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Write the five class criteria from memory. Next to each, write how we will measure it today.
How will we measure “at least 8 of 10 test visitors can explain one piece of evidence afterward”?
Designers, today ten visitors decide. They might be students from another class, staff or family members. None of them has seen our exhibit.
Our class criteria, from 3.09:
Test plan. 1. Each visitor walks the four stations alone. 2. A Timer records minutes at each station. 3. A Counter tallies which senses the visitor used. 4. At the exit, an Interviewer asks: “Tell me one piece of evidence that life has changed over time.” and records whether the answer is correct. 5. At least one visitor tests with a sleep mask and guide, and one with earmuffs. 6. The Budget Keeper totals the sample costs.
Worked example 1: reading test data (sample data).
| Station | Senses used | Average time (min) | Longest time (min) | Met criteria? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fossil layers | touch, hearing, sight | 2.2 | 2.8 | yes |
| Comparing limbs | touch, sight | 1.9 | 2.5 | yes |
| Embryos | touch, hearing, sight | 2.6 | 3.4 | time: no |
| Ecosystems | touch, sight | 2.4 | 2.9 | yes |
Exit interviews: 8 of 10 visitors explained one piece of evidence correctly. Sample budget: $118 of $120 spent. Kofi’s analysis: “We met four criteria fully. The embryos station averaged under 3 minutes, but one visitor needed 3.4 minutes, so we did not meet the criterion for every visitor. Our final fix: cut the audio clip from 30 to 15 seconds.”
Worked example 2: honest limits. Mei added: “Only one no-sight visitor and one no-hearing visitor tested. That is a small sample, so we will tell the museum that more testing would help.” Naming a limitation makes the results more trustworthy, not less.
Collect your data, then analyze it with these.
Write the test report the museum will read.
Claim: did our exhibit meet the museum's criteria? Evidence: at least three numbers from today's test. Reasoning: explain which criteria were met, which were not, and your final fix. Name one limitation of the test.
Data in hand, designers. Next class is Museum Opening Night.
Exit ticket: which criterion was hardest to meet, and what does that tell you about designing for real visitors?
How confident are you that you can I can evaluate a solution using the criteria and constraints we defined.
Materials: version 2 exhibit, timers, tally sheets, exit interview cards, sleep masks and earmuffs, wipes, budget sheets.
Setup: arrange ten test visitors in advance (another class, staff or volunteers). Assign roles: Timer, Counter, Interviewer, Guide, Budget Keeper. Run visitors in pairs of teams to keep the time to about 25 minutes. All numbers in the example are sample data.
Listen for: averages used to hide a failing visitor; “we met it because most people liked it”; teams that skip the limitation.
Support / stretch: give a pre-built scorecard. Stretch: graph each station’s times as a dot plot and mark the 3-minute line.