
define and, where possible, measure the criteria and constraints for the impact monitor, including what our clients need and its cost limit.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Reread the green team’s and watershed group’s request. Underline every word that tells us what a successful monitor must do or must not do.
Which is a constraint rather than a criterion?
Explore first. In teams, sort sticky notes from the request, the Wonder Board and our investigations into two columns: things the monitor must achieve, and limits it must work within. Then the class agrees on one shared list.
Our class criteria and constraints.
| # | Criterion or constraint | How we will measure it | Our first design’s plan | Met? (Yes/No/Not yet) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | The monitor measures at least 2 impacts weekly (for example water use and runoff, or waste). | Count the impacts in the weekly log | ||
| 2 | It includes 1 action that cuts an impact by at least 10% in a 2-week sample test. | Compare 2 weeks before and 2 weeks after the action | ||
| 3 | Students run it in under 10 minutes a week. | Time one full weekly check | ||
| 4 | It costs under the sample budget ($150). | Add up a parts list | ||
| 5 | It supports local biodiversity. | Name the species or service helped and the evidence |
Name the ideas. Criteria describe what a successful solution must do. Constraints are limits such as cost, time, space, safety and school rules. Good criteria are measurable, so two people testing the same design would agree on the result.
Worked example 1: making a criterion measurable. Ava’s team wrote, “Use less water.” The class changed it to “cut an impact by at least 10% in a 2-week sample test.” Sample data: if the baseline is 400 L a week, a 10% cut means at most 400 − 40 = 360 L a week.
Worked example 2: checking the budget. Sample prices: a rain gauge $15, a plug-in energy meter $30, a bucket and scale $25, and native seed mix $40. The total is $110, which is under the $150 sample budget, leaving $40 for spare parts.
People’s needs count too. The green team needs a monitor students can actually keep running, so the 10-minute limit matters. The watershed group needs data about runoff and habitat, so criterion 5 matters.
Test your understanding of the class list.
Apply the list to a first idea.
Sketch a first idea for your team's monitor. Fill in the “Our first design's plan” column for all five rows, including a sample parts list with a total cost.
Which criterion will be hardest for your idea to meet? Explain what limit makes it hard.
Our list is set. Next, in Make Sense, we use our evidence to explain the science and choose ideas that can meet it.
Exit ticket: name one criterion and one constraint for the monitor. For each, explain how we will measure it and which client need it comes from.
Materials: sticky notes in two colors, chart paper with the five-row table, sample price list, calculators.
Setup: guide the class to these exact five criteria and constraints; part 2 of the unit tests against them. If your class needs a different budget, swap in your number everywhere ($150 is our sample). Post the list for the rest of the unit.
Listen for: vague criteria (“helps the earth”) and confusion between criteria and constraints. Point out that the 10% cut is checked against a baseline, which we began in 4.04.
Support / stretch: offer a sort mat with examples already placed. Stretch: propose a sixth criterion with a measurable target and argue why a stakeholder would want it.