
ask testable questions about patterns in global temperature and carbon dioxide data from the past century and what has caused the changes.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Weather is what happens today; climate is the pattern over many years. Write one example of each from your own life.
A graph shows Earth's average temperature each year since 1880. What shape do you expect?
Explore first. Teams study three graphs: global average temperature change since 1880, carbon dioxide (CO2) in the atmosphere over the same years, and the amount of fossil fuel burned worldwide. Note patterns and write every question that comes to mind.
| Graph | Pattern I notice | When does it change fastest? | A question it raises | Data that could answer it |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Global temperature change | ||||
| Atmospheric CO2 | ||||
| Fossil fuel use |
Name the ideas. The greenhouse effect is natural: gases such as CO2, methane and water vapor trap some of Earth’s heat, which keeps the planet livable. Burning coal, oil and natural gas adds extra CO2. CO2 was about 280 parts per million before the 1800s and is above 400 today. Scientists also checked natural causes, such as changes in sunlight and volcanic eruptions, and those do not explain the recent rise. Human activities, mainly burning fossil fuels, are the main cause of recent warming.
Worked example 1: from notice to question. Priya noticed that CO2 and temperature both rise faster in the second half of the century. Her first question, “Is it all bad?”, is hard to test. She revised it: “Did the faster rise in CO2 match a faster rise in fossil fuel burning?” That question names data that could answer it.
Worked example 2: separating causes. Diego saw a dip in temperature for a year or two after a large volcanic eruption. He asked, “How do eruptions affect global temperature, and how long does the effect last?” This question helps separate short natural changes from the long-term trend.
Staying calm and curious. Climate change is real and serious, and people around the world are already working on solutions. Good questions lead to good evidence, and evidence leads to good choices.
Use the graphs and your question list. Discuss each card with your team.
Build a question bank for the class.
Write three questions about the data: one about the temperature pattern, one about CO2 and fossil fuels, and one about a natural system such as glaciers, sea ice or animal migrations. Name the data that could answer each one.
How confident are you that you can I can ask testable questions about global temperature data.
We return to our question bank in 4.11, when we model the greenhouse effect. Next time: what soil and plants do for water, for free.
Exit ticket: write one question about a pattern that links a human activity to global temperature or CO2 change. Then explain what data would answer it.
Materials: printed or projected graphs from a reputable public science agency of global temperature change since 1880, atmospheric CO2 and global fossil-fuel use; sticky notes for the question bank.
Setup: use a question-formulation protocol: write freely, sort into open and closed, then improve two. Keep the question bank posted for 4.11.
Listen for: anxiety (“we’re doomed”) and doubt (“it’s just natural”). Answer both with evidence and calm: the warming is real, mainly caused by people burning fossil fuels, and people are acting on it. Separate weather from climate. Some students may have lived through extreme weather; be gentle and never ask them to share.
Support / stretch: give stems: “Why did ___ change after ___?” “What would happen to ___ if ___?” Stretch: explain why scientists use 30-year averages rather than single years.