
use a weighted decision matrix to compare the three exhibit designs and make an evidence-based claim about which works best.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Your friend group must pick one movie. Five people vote, and the winner gets 3 votes. Is that a fair way to choose for a museum? Write one reason it might not be.
If we score the three designs on our criteria, which do you think will win?
Designers, a vote counts opinions. A decision matrix counts evidence. A decision matrix is a table that scores each design against each criterion. Some criteria matter more, so we give them a weight, a number that multiplies the score.
How to build one. 1. List the criteria and constraints as rows. 2. Agree on weights as a team (3 = must have, 2 = important, 1 = nice to have). 3. Score each design from 1 (poor) to 5 (excellent), using evidence, not feelings. 4. Multiply score by weight. 5. Add each column.
Worked example 1: one row. Accessibility has weight 3. The Touch Table scores 3 (great for touch, weak without audio). The Audio Tour scores 2 (great for listeners, weak for visitors who cannot hear). The Flip-Panel Timeline scores 2. Weighted: 9, 6 and 6.
| Criterion (weight) | Touch Table | Audio Tour | Flip-Panel Timeline |
|---|---|---|---|
| At least 2 senses (3) | 5 → 15 | 2 → 6 | 2 → 6 |
| Under 3 minutes (2) | 4 → 8 | 4 → 8 | 5 → 10 |
| 8 of 10 explain evidence (3) | 4 → 12 | 3 → 9 | 3 → 9 |
| Accessible (3) | 3 → 9 | 2 → 6 | 2 → 6 |
| Within budget (2) | 3 → 6 | 5 → 10 | 4 → 8 |
| Total | 50 | 39 | 39 |
Sample data. Your team’s scores will differ.
Worked example 2: a claim from the matrix. Jamal wrote: “The Touch Table is the best choice, with 50 points. Its strength is that every station uses touch and sight. Its weakness is accessibility for visitors who cannot see, so we will add the best part of the Audio Tour: a short spoken clip at each station.” He named the winner, a strength, a weakness and a fix.
Notice: the winning design can borrow from the losers. Engineers often combine the strongest features of competing designs.
Use the sample matrix, then build your team’s own.
Fill in your team’s matrix.
Copy the matrix with your team's weights. Score all three designs, give one piece of evidence for each score in the Accessible row, and total the columns.
Claim: which design (or hybrid) will we build? Evidence: the totals and two rows. Reasoning: why this design best meets the museum's needs, and what you will borrow from another design.
Your team has a plan backed by evidence. Next class: what real museums already know about hands-on, accessible exhibits.
Exit ticket: name the design your team chose, its biggest strength and its biggest weakness.
How confident are you that you can I can use a decision matrix to find the strengths and weaknesses of each solution.
Materials: blank matrix templates (paper or spreadsheet), calculators, the design tables from 3.15, any material price list you have for the sample budget.
Setup: do the first matrix row as a class so teams agree on what a 1 and a 5 mean. Teams that choose a hybrid design are doing exactly what engineers do.
Listen for: scores without evidence; “the highest total always wins” (a design that scores 1 on a must-have may still be rejected); weight arguments that are really about personal taste.
Support / stretch: give a pre-filled matrix with two rows missing. Stretch: test how sensitive the result is by changing one weight and recalculating.