
write an evidence-based argument that growth in population and per-person resource use changes Earth’s systems, and judge whether the evidence is enough.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Look back at your 4.03 graphs and 4.04 audit. Write the one piece of evidence you think is strongest for showing that people change Earth’s systems.
Which piece of evidence best supports a CAUSE, not just a correlation?
Reading: how resource use reshapes Earth. When a region’s population grows, people need more homes, roads, food, water and energy. When each person also uses more, the demand grows even faster. Meeting that demand changes Earth’s systems. Land is cleared or paved, which changes habitats and runoff. Water is pumped from rivers and aquifers, which can lower water tables and shrink wetlands. Fuel is burned for energy, which adds carbon dioxide to the atmosphere. Waste goes to landfills or escapes into water. Not every change is equally large, and new technology can reduce the impact per person. Efficient faucets, for example, cut water use without cutting the number of users.
Claim, Evidence, Reasoning. A claim answers the question. Evidence is data that supports it. Reasoning explains why the evidence supports the claim, using science ideas. Strong arguments also consider a counterclaim and explain why the evidence fits the claim better.
Worked example 1: a strong CER. Claim: in our sample region, growth in population and per-person water use has shrunk the wetland. Evidence: population grew 3 times and per-person use grew 1.5 times, so total use grew 4.5 times; over the same years, wetland area shrank. Reasoning: total use equals people times use per person, and pumping more water lowers the water table that keeps wetlands wet.
Worked example 2: is the evidence enough? Malik asked whether the wetland could have shrunk from a long drought instead. That is a reasonable counterclaim. To answer it, the team checked sample rainfall records, which showed no long-term drop. The evidence now rules out one other explanation, so the claim is stronger. If rainfall had dropped, they would need more evidence before claiming cause.
Evaluate evidence and build your CER. Discuss each card with your team.
Write your CER. Use these sentence starters if they help: I claim that… My evidence is… This evidence supports my claim because… Someone might argue…, but… My evidence is (or is not yet) enough because…
CER: How do increases in population and per-person resource use affect Earth's systems? Use at least two pieces of evidence from 4.03–4.07, explain the chain from people to resources to Earth systems, answer one counterclaim, and judge whether your evidence is strong enough to show cause and effect.
Next time we model the atmosphere and return to our climate question bank.
Exit ticket: name one piece of evidence you used and explain whether it is necessary, sufficient or both for your claim.
Materials: students’ 4.03 graphs and 4.04–4.07 tables, a printed sample rainfall record for the generic region (flat trend), CER organizer, the scoring guide below.
CER scoring (0–2 each, PSSA-style): claim; evidence (2 = two relevant data points with numbers); reasoning (2 = explains the population × per-capita chain and an Earth-system mechanism); counterclaim and sufficiency.
Listen for: claims that blame a group of people, and correlation treated as cause. Redirect to mechanisms and to per-capita use, which varies widely.
Support / stretch: give a partly completed CER with the claim filled in. Stretch: argue whether population growth or per-capita growth mattered more in the sample region, using the 3 and 1.5 growth factors.