
evaluate competing designs that protect biodiversity and ecosystem services, and choose an add-on for our monitor using evidence.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Remember our phenomenon: a local wetland that once had many kinds of frogs now has only a few. Write two things that flow from our school grounds toward that wetland.
Rain falls on a mowed lawn and on a bed of deep-rooted native plants. Which soaks up more water?
The missing criterion. None of our trial designs supported local biodiversity. Today we design an add-on that does, and that also helps with runoff. Remember from grade 6: an ecosystem with many kinds of living things is usually more stable when conditions change.
Ecosystem services are benefits that healthy ecosystems give people for free. Plants and soil filter water (water purification), roots hold soil in place (erosion control), decomposers return nutrients to soil (nutrient recycling), and insects pollinate crops and flowers.
Three competing add-ons (sample site plan).
| Sample data (one season, small test plots) | Plant species | Pollinator visits in 10 min | Runoff soaked in | Cost | Weekly upkeep |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rain garden | 12 | 9 | Most roof runoff from one downspout | $90 | 5 min |
| Native plant strip | 15 | 14 | Some | $80 | 2 min |
| Mowed lawn | 3 | 1 | Little | $0 | Mowing by staff |
Worked example 1: comparing with evidence. Carlos says: “The native strip had the most plant species (15) and pollinator visits (14), so it supports biodiversity best. The rain garden is close behind (12 and 9) but captures far more runoff, which protects the creek and wetland.”
Worked example 2: side effects. Yuki checks for ripple effects. “If we plant a fast-spreading non-native plant, it could escape into the wetland and crowd out native plants. A rain garden that stays soggy for days could breed mosquitoes, so it must drain well.” A small change in one place can cause bigger changes elsewhere.
Criteria for the add-on (set together). Supports more species than lawn; improves at least one ecosystem service; keeps the whole monitor under the $150 sample budget and our 10-minute weekly routine; no invasive species.
Use the sample data table. Discuss each block with your team.
Write a recommendation for the watershed group.
Recommend one add-on (or a combination). Use at least two numbers from the sample data, name the ecosystem services it supports, and explain one possible side effect and how you would prevent it.
Explain why biodiversity near the school could matter for the frogs in the wetland downstream.
Your monitor now has a living part. Next class, other teams will critique your full design.
Exit ticket: name one ecosystem service your add-on provides and the evidence that it works.
How confident are you that you can I can compare design solutions that protect biodiversity and ecosystem services.
Materials: site map of the school grounds with downspouts marked, photos of rain gardens and native plant strips, a list of plants native to your region from a local extension office or native plant society, gloves.
Setup: the plot data are sample data. If you have time, run a real 10-minute pollinator count on a sunny day. Get permission from facilities before marking any planting site. Students wash hands after handling soil or plants.
Listen for: “any green plant is good”; “rain gardens are ponds” (they drain within a day or two); forgetting the time criterion. The two time blocks are meant to surface that 8 + 2 is not under 10.
Support / stretch: give a strengths/weaknesses T-chart. Stretch: estimate roof area for one downspout and size a rain garden in proportion.