
give and use peer critique to revise our station, and describe how lab technicians and microscopists use the same skills.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Think of a time someone gave you feedback that actually helped. What made it useful instead of hurtful?
Which comment is the most useful critique?
The protocol: I like, I wonder, What if. Teams set their station, gallery photos and data on the table. Visiting teams have 4 minutes per station. They write one “I like” (a strength tied to a criterion), one “I wonder” (a question about a weakness) and one “What if” (an idea to try). Then teams rotate.
Worked example 1: turning critique into a change. Ava’s team built the clip-on lens design. They get three notes: “I like that the image saves in two taps.” “I wonder why the nucleus is fuzzy.” “What if you used a stack of coins to fix the lens height?” The fuzzy nucleus is a clarity problem, the highest-weighted criterion. The team tests the coin stack and the clarity score rises from 3 to 4 (sample data).
Worked example 2: rescoring after revision. After version 2, the team updates its decision matrix: clarity 4 × 3 = 12, cost 5 × 2 = 10, sharing 4 × 2 = 8, setup 4 × 1 = 4. New total = 34, up from 32. Setup dropped one point because the coin stack adds a step. That trade-off goes in the presentation.
| Feedback we got | Criterion it affects | Change we made | Evidence it helped |
|---|---|---|---|
Run the critique rotation, then use these blocks to plan your revision.
Build version 2 and reflect.
Rescore your version 2 in the decision matrix. Did the total change? Name one strength and one weakness that remain.
Which piece of feedback did you NOT use? Explain why, using the criteria and constraints.
Version 2 is ready, design engineers. Next: the image-quality test against every criterion.
Exit ticket: which critique helped most, and what is your evidence that the change worked?
How confident are you that you can I can use evidence and reasoning to claim which solution works best.
Materials: sticky notes in three colors (I like, I wonder, What if), every team’s version 1 and gallery photos, coins or washers, white cards, tape, the matrix sheets.
Setup: model one round of critique with a teacher-built station first. Rotate every 4 minutes for three rounds, then 15 minutes to revise. Training paths for lab careers vary; keep the career talk general.
Listen for: critiques of people instead of designs; teams changing many things at once so they cannot tell which change helped.
Support / stretch: give sentence stems for each critique type. Stretch: ask teams to test two revisions separately and compare.