
use evidence from texts, graphs and our relay data to argue that digital signals are more reliable than analog for storing and sharing cell images.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Look at this sample graph description. Line A (analog) starts at 100% image quality and falls with every copy. Line B (digital) stays flat at 100%. Then predict.
If both lines went to 20 copies, what would you expect?
Reading: how digital images changed science. For a long time, scientists recorded what they saw through microscopes by drawing it by hand, and later on photographic film. Drawings depend on the artist, and film copies lose detail and fade. Today most microscope cameras store images as grids of pixels. Each pixel is a number, and numbers can be copied exactly, stored for years and sent across the world in seconds. Scientists in different countries can study the same image at the same moment. Space probes send their images back to Earth as digital signals for the same reason: over a long trip, a digital message can be checked for errors and rebuilt, while an analog one would arrive full of noise.
Where evidence comes from. Strong arguments use more than one kind of source: our own relay data (3.08), a graph, a short text or a video. Each source should be trustworthy, for example a science museum, a university or a science agency.
Worked example 1: reading a graph as evidence. Sample data: after 5 copies, the analog image kept about 60% of its detail and the digital image kept 100%. Malik wrote, “The graph shows analog quality fell by about 40 points in 5 copies, while digital did not change. This supports the claim that digital copies are more reliable.”
Worked example 2: a full argument. Ava wrote: “Claim: the clinic should store and send cell images as digital files. Evidence: in our relay, the number grid matched 100% after four copies while the traced wave did not. The reading says digital images can be stored for years and sent long distances without losing detail. Reasoning: a digital signal is a code of separate values, so a little noise does not change it, and errors can be checked. Families will get the same sharp image the class saw.”
Weigh each piece of evidence.
Write your argument.
Write a CER for the clinic: should the station store and send images digitally? Use at least two different kinds of sources (our relay data, the graph or the reading). Include one way digital imaging has helped science learn about cells.
How confident are you that you can I can use evidence from several sources to argue that digital signals are more reliable.
We now have all the science we need. Next time, we brainstorm station designs and check them against our design brief.
Exit ticket: name one technology that uses digital encoding to share images, and explain one feature that makes it more reliable than an analog version.
Materials: relay data from 3.08, a printed sample graph (two lines, labeled sample data), the short reading, CER template. Optional: a short video from a science museum about digital imaging.
Setup: draw the sample graph on the board as students read the description. Emphasize that its numbers are sample data.
Listen for: “digital never fails.” Files can be lost or compressed; the advantage is that exact copies and error checking are possible. Keep the space probe example general, with no device mechanisms (MS-PS4-3 boundary).
Support / stretch: give a two-source evidence organizer. Stretch: explain why more pixels mean more detail but bigger files, and what trade-off that creates for families with limited phone data.