
pitch our breeding plan to the community farm, explaining the science, the model data and the trade-offs, and answer the farm’s questions with evidence.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. The farm’s growers have five minutes for each team. Write the one sentence you most want them to remember.
Which opening best fits the farm?
Breeders, welcome to Farm Field Day. Growers and volunteers from the community farm visit in person or by video. They will decide which plan to try next season.
Your five-minute pitch. 1. The problem and the criteria. 2. The three plans you compared and the features you combined. 3. The science: variation, Punnett squares and selection over generations. 4. Your model, its test data and its limitations. 5. Trade-offs, ethics and your recommendation.
Worked example 1: the science, simply. Kofi said: “Bean plants made from seeds get genes from two parents, so they vary. Crossing in a tolerant donor adds a helpful variant. Each dry season, tolerant plants are more likely to survive and make seed, so the tolerant share rises. That is the same process as natural selection, sped up by choosing the seed.”
Worked example 2: trade-offs and ethics, honestly. Sofia said: “A modified variety would work fast, and approved ones are considered safe to eat, but it would cost $750, give you one line and may not allow seed saving. Our plan is slower in year 2 and may change flavor a little, so we suggest tasting each line as you select. Our model uses one gene; real fields may be slower, which is why we built in a margin.”
Rehearse with your team before the farm arrives.
After all the pitches, reflect.
What did a grower ask or suggest? Name one idea from another team you would borrow and explain why.
Write a one-paragraph recommendation to the farm. Use data from at least two teams and name one trade-off.
Design, model, test and pitch a breeding plan that helps a community farm grow beans that survive dry summers. The plan must have at least 70% of plants surviving a sample dry year within 5 generations, keep at least 3 parent lines, fit the farm’s sample budget of $300 over five seasons, and explain every trade-off. Defend it with Punnett squares, a generation-by-generation bead or spreadsheet model, and Dry-Year Test Day data.
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Comparing and combining designs | Three plans are compared in an organized table; the claim names the best feature of each with data and combines them into a plan that meets the criteria. |
| Science of heredity and selection | The pitch correctly explains variation from sexual reproduction and mutations, uses a Punnett square to predict each cross, and explains with proportions why tolerant plants become more common over generations. |
| Model and testing | The model shows inputs, outputs and criteria; data from several trials and weather patterns is graphed and compared with every criterion; limitations are named and used to improve the plan. |
| Communication, trade-offs and ethics | Every member speaks; the recommendation is clear; benefits, risks and ethics of the technologies are explained fairly with credible sources; trade-offs are honest. |
You gave real advice to real growers, breeders. Next: the unit checkpoint, then two catch-up and stretch days.
Exit ticket: which Wonder Board question can you now answer? Write the question and your answer.
How confident are you that you can I can defend a design to a client with data and science.
Materials: team graphs and criteria tables on posters or slides, rubric copies for visitors, a few labeled bean seed packets as props, timer.
Setup: invite growers or volunteers from a community farm or garden, a local extension educator, or staff who can role-play them; a video call works. Visitors can score the “Communication, trade-offs and ethics” row.
Listen for: “the plants learned to handle drought”; one-sided claims about modified crops; skipping limitations.
Support / stretch: give a five-box pitch frame and note cards. Stretch: add a plan for selecting flavor alongside drought tolerance and explain its trade-off.