
give and use peer feedback and model data to improve our breeding plan, and explain how each change helps it meet the criteria.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Write the one weakness in your plan that worries you most after yesterday’s wet-year test. Then write one question you want a classmate to answer about it.
Which feedback is most useful to a team?
Breeders, real breeding programs improve their plans every season. Today you will critique, then build version 2.
Protocol: I like, I wonder, What if. Each team gets 3 minutes to show its plan and data. Reviewers write one I like (a strength, with data), one I wonder (a question about a criterion) and one What if (a specific change). The presenting team only listens and writes until the end.
Worked example 1: turning feedback into a change. Priya’s team heard: “What if the farm did not have to wait for a dry year to select?” They researched how breeders handle this and found that many use a managed dry test plot. Version 2 adds a small dry test bed where the farm withholds water each summer and saves seed only from plants that stay green there. Selection now happens every year. Extra cost: $30 of supplies (sample). New total: $130, still under $300.
Worked example 2: testing version 2. In the spreadsheet, the weather pattern no longer matters for selection, because the test bed is always dry. Generation 5 survival is about 79% under every weather pattern, compared with 74% before in the dry-wet pattern. Version 2 meets the 70% criterion with room to spare, which also covers the model’s limitation that real Dd parents can make some dd seeds.
| Feedback | Change we made | Criterion it helps | Model data before | Model data after |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Run the critique rounds, then answer these as a team.
Write version 2.
Fill in the feedback table with two changes. For each, give the model data before and after and the criterion it helps.
Explain how each part of version 2 (donor cross, heirloom lines, dry test bed, seed saving) helps solve the farm's problem.
Version 2 is ready for its final test. Next class: Dry-Year Test Day.
Exit ticket: name the most important change in version 2 and the data that shows it worked.
How confident are you that you can I can use test data and feedback to improve a design.
Materials: each team’s spreadsheet and graphs, critique forms (I like / I wonder / What if), timer.
Setup: run two or three critique rounds, 6 minutes each. Teams may choose a different version 2 change (for example, a fifth line, or a second donor); accept any change that is tested in the model and rechecked against all criteria. The $30 cost is sample data.
Listen for: feedback without data; teams that change the plan but do not retest.
Support / stretch: give critique sentence frames. Stretch: research one way genetic counselors explain probability to families, and compare it with how you will explain risk to the farm.