
graph cup-push data from marbles of different mass and speed and describe how kinetic energy depends on each.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. A pebble and a car-sized boulder roll down the same gully at the same speed. Which one would you rather stand in front of, and why?
A marble rolls twice as fast as before. How much harder does it push a paper cup?
Engineers, a barrier must absorb the energy of motion. Remember from grade 6 that a force can change an object’s motion. Now we measure what a moving boulder brings to the barrier: its kinetic energy, the energy an object has because it is moving. We compare kinetic energy by how far a marble pushes a paper cup at the bottom of the ramp: more push, more energy.
The investigation. Test 1 changes only the mass: release a 5 g, 10 g and 20 g marble from the same 1 m mark. Test 2 changes only the speed: release the 10 g marble from three marks, time its last 20 cm, and find its speed. Run three trials each and average them.
| Test | Mass (g) | Speed (m/s) | Cup push trial 1 (cm) | Trial 2 | Trial 3 | Average (cm) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mass | 5 | same | ||||
| Mass | 10 | same | ||||
| Mass | 20 | same | ||||
| Speed | 10 | |||||
| Speed | 10 | |||||
| Speed | 10 |
Worked example 1: mass (sample data). Mei’s team averaged 4 cm for 5 g, 8 cm for 10 g and 16 cm for 20 g. On a graph of push against mass, the points fall on a straight line through zero. Doubling the mass doubled the push. Kinetic energy is proportional to mass.
Worked example 2: speed (sample data). Jamal’s team measured 0.5 m/s → 2 cm, 1.0 m/s → 8 cm and 1.5 m/s → 18 cm. The graph curves upward. From 0.5 to 1.0 m/s the speed doubled, but the push went from 2 to 8 cm, four times as far. Speed matters more than mass: doubling speed gives about four times the kinetic energy.
What it means for the east gully. A storm that makes boulders move faster is far more dangerous than one that just adds a few heavier rocks. Your barrier must handle the fastest marbles, not the average ones.
Use your data and the simulation. Add a note to your graph after each block.
Make your graphs.
Draw two graphs from your data: cup push against mass, and cup push against speed. Label the axes with units and describe the shape of each line.
Use your graphs to explain which matters more for barrier design, a heavier boulder or a faster one. Cite numbers.
Now you know what your barrier is up against. Next class, you build version 1 and send your fastest boulders at it.
Exit ticket: a boulder's speed doubles in a big storm. Is its kinetic energy more or less than doubled? Explain with your graph.
How confident are you that you can I can use a graph to identify how kinetic energy changes with mass and speed.
Materials (per team): a 1 m ramp (foam-board or cardboard channel 30 cm wide, or a split pool noodle), books to prop it, marbles of about 5 g, 10 g and 20 g (or a steel ball), a paper cup with a doorway cut in it, meter stick, stopwatch or phone slow-motion video, kitchen scale, goggles.
Setup: tape release marks at 25 cm, 50 cm and 100 cm along the ramp for the speed test. Speed = 0.2 m ÷ time for the last 20 cm; students only compare speeds and ratios, with no kinetic energy formula. Real data will be messier than the sample, because of friction and rolling; that is a good discussion point.
Listen for: “heavier things fall faster so they have more energy”; “double speed means double energy.”
Support / stretch: give pre-labeled graph axes. Stretch: predict the cup push at 2.0 m/s from the pattern, then explain why it is hard to test on our ramp.