
use graphs and tables to explain how a debris flow’s kinetic energy depends on its mass and its speed, and what that means for a barrier.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Sketch two quick graphs from memory: kinetic energy versus mass and kinetic energy versus speed. Label which one is straight and which one curves.
Two debris flows have the same mass. Flow B moves 3 times as fast as flow A. How does B's kinetic energy compare?
Reading: why speed is the big danger. A debris flow carries kinetic energy because it has mass and moves. When it hits a wall, that energy goes into pushing, breaking and bending things. Two factors set how much energy it carries. More mass means proportionally more energy: twice the mud and rock, twice the energy. Speed counts far more. Doubling speed makes four times the energy, and tripling it makes nine times. That is why a steep gully is so dangerous, and why barriers are often placed where the slope eases and flows slow down.
Model first: a class data table. Pool every team’s 1.07 averages. Then copy the sample data below and graph both relationships.
| Sample run | Mass (g) | Speed (m/s) | Cup slide (cm) | Compared with run A |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | 20 | 1.2 | 10 | — |
| B | 40 | 1.2 | 20 | |
| C | 20 | 2.4 | 40 | |
| D | 40 | 2.4 |
Worked example 1: reading a ratio from a table. Compare runs A and B. Speed stayed at 1.2 m/s, mass doubled from 20 g to 40 g, and the slide doubled from 10 cm to 20 cm. Ratio: 2 times the mass, 2 times the energy.
Worked example 2: combining both. Run D has twice the mass AND twice the speed of run A. Doubling mass gives 2 times; doubling speed gives 4 times. Together, 2 × 4 = 8 times the energy, so we predict about 80 cm of slide. Jamal tested it and got 74 cm (sample), close to the prediction, given friction and measuring error.
Worked example 3: a good graph. Priya put the variable she changed (speed) on the x-axis and the result (slide) on the y-axis, with units, a title and an even scale starting at zero. A good graph makes the curve easy to see.
Use the sample table and your two graphs.
Graph and explain.
Graph the sample table twice: slide versus mass (runs A and B) and slide versus speed (runs A and C). Add titles, units and scales. Describe how each graph shows a linear or nonlinear relationship.
Explain to the board, using ratios, why slowing a debris flow is more effective than making it smaller by the same fraction.
We understand the energy our barrier must handle. Next time, we brainstorm barrier designs.
How confident are you that you can I can use graphs to show that kinetic energy is proportional to mass and grows with the square of speed.
Exit ticket: a flow's speed triples. By what factor does its kinetic energy change? Explain in one sentence.
Materials: graph paper, rulers, pooled class data from 1.07, the sample table.
Setup: run D’s predicted value (80 cm) and Jamal’s 74 cm are sample data. Real cup slides are noisy; praise reasoning about error.
Boundary: ratios and graphs only; no kinetic energy formula calculations.
Support / stretch: give pre-scaled axes and a ratio frame (“___ times the ___ gives ___ times the energy”). Stretch: use the Energy Skate Park sim to check the triple-speed prediction qualitatively.