
organize and analyze data from three breeding plans, and combine their best features into a hybrid plan that better meets the farm’s criteria.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Look back at the plan table from 2.15. Write the single best feature of each plan in five words or fewer.
Plan A is cheap and keeps 4 lines, but starts at 45% survival. Plan B starts at 80% but keeps only 2 lines. What might a combined plan do?
Breeders, engineers rarely pick one design as it is. They study test data, find the best features of each design and combine them. Today you will do that for the farm.
Step 1: organize the data. A scoring table gives each plan 2 points for meeting a criterion, 1 for partly meeting it and 0 for missing it. The last column is an extra goal the farm cares about.
| Plan | 70% survival by gen 5 | 3+ parent lines | Budget ($300) | Fewest losses in early years | Total /8 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A. Select and save | 2 | 2 | 2 | 0 | 6 |
| B. Cross two varieties | 2 | 0 | 2 | 2 | 6 |
| C. Buy modified | 2 | 0 | 0 | 2 | 4 |
| Hybrid (your design) |
Worked example 1: similarities and differences. Sofia compares A and B: “Both reach about 78% by generation 4 or 5, because both save seed from survivors. They differ early: B starts at 80% because the donor’s D variant makes every generation 1 plant tolerant, while A starts at 45%. A keeps 4 lines; B keeps only 2.”
Worked example 2: combining the best features. Tomas’s team designs a hybrid: “Buy one packet of a bred drought-tolerant donor from a seed bank program ($60, sample price). Cross it into three heirloom lines and keep the fourth heirloom pure as a backup. Then select and save survivors each season.” Their check: survival follows Plan B’s path (80%, 68%, 74%, 78%, 79%), parent lines = donor + 3 heirlooms = 4, and cost = $60 + $40 supplies = $100. It scores 2 on every column: 8 out of 8.
Notice the trade-off. Crossing in a donor mixes new genes into each heirloom, so flavor or color may change. Selecting for taste as well as survival is the farm’s next decision.
Score, compare and combine with your team.
Design your team’s hybrid.
Write your team's hybrid plan in 4–6 numbered steps. Name which plan each feature came from and fill in the hybrid row of the scoring table.
Name one trade-off your hybrid creates for the farm and how you will explain it to them.
Your hybrid looks strong on paper. Next class: a mid-build checkpoint, then we test the plan in a model.
Exit ticket: name the best feature you borrowed and the data that convinced you.
How confident are you that you can I can use data to combine the best features of several designs.
Materials: plan table and scoring table on a poster, sticky notes for features, calculators.
Setup: the “fewest losses in early years” column is an extra comparison the farm cares about, not one of the four class criteria. All prices are sample data. Teams may design different hybrids; any hybrid that keeps 3+ lines and stays in budget is valid.
Listen for: combining features without checking every criterion again; ignoring flavor and other traits the farm values.
Support / stretch: provide feature cards to sort into “keep” and “drop.” Stretch: add a weighting so survival counts double, and see whether the ranking changes.