
revise my barrier using test data and critique, retest it, and explain the improvement using kinetic energy and the decision matrix.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Read your version 1 test table and your top two sticky notes. Write your revision plan in one sentence: “We will change ___ so that ___.”
Why should a team change only one or two things in version 2?
Engineers, revision is where good designs become great. Today you build version 2, run the same 10-marble test and pour test, and compare.
Our class criteria, from 1.09. A barrier must (1) stop at least 9 of 10 marble “boulders” released from the top of a 1 m ramp, (2) let water drain through, (3) cost no more than 10 sample “budget points,” and (4) fit a 30 cm wide channel.
Worked example 1: slowing the boulder before it hits (sample data). Diego’s mesh fence failed on the heavy top marbles. His team added two rows of staggered craft-stick posts in front (10 sticks, 2 points, total 9). The posts take some speed out of each marble first. Because kinetic energy depends on the square of speed, cutting a marble’s speed in half leaves only about one quarter of its energy for the mesh. Result: 10 of 10 stopped, water drained, 9 points. Every criterion met.
Worked example 2: cutting cost without losing strength. Priya’s posts-plus-basin cost 12 points. Her team removed one mesh square (2 points) and wove the pipe cleaners she already had into a drain grid instead. Cost dropped to 10 points. It stopped 9 of 10. She re-scored her matrix: the design now beats her old one on cost and only drops 1 point on stopping.
| Criterion | Version 1 result | Version 2 result | Better, same or worse? | Why (science or design reason) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Boulders stopped (of 10) | ||||
| Water drains | ||||
| Budget points | ||||
| Fits 30 cm channel |
Build for 15 minutes, then retest. Answer between trials.
Compare and claim.
Complete the version 1 versus version 2 table. Then write a claim: is version 2 the better solution? Use evidence from both tests and your re-scored decision matrix.
Explain your biggest improvement using kinetic energy: what happened to the mass or speed of the boulders, and how did that change the energy your barrier had to absorb?
Version 2 is ready for Barrier Trial Day. Next: the Prove It phase begins, and the Build field trip, The Barrier Test Channel, comes after this lesson.
Exit ticket: what is the one weakness version 2 still has, and how will you explain it honestly to the planning board?
How confident are you that you can I can use evidence and reasoning to claim which solution works best.
Materials: version 1 barriers, the store with price-list materials, ramps, the same marble sets as 1.19, water and trays, goggles.
Setup: teams may spend only up to 10 total points, so swaps must be traded back to the store. Keep the 1.19 release marks and order.
Listen for: teams that change everything at once; claims without numbers; “half the speed means half the energy.”
Support / stretch: give a one-change planning card. Stretch: find the lowest-cost design that still stops 9 of 10.