
show what I learned about rock layers, resources, hazard forecasts, kinetic energy and engineering design, using PSSA-style questions.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Back to our phenomenon: a hillside gives way after days of rain, and a nearby road cut holds seashells, coal and ash. In two sentences, explain what the road cut says about the past and why the hillside failed.
In undisturbed rock layers, the layer with seashells at the bottom of the road cut is the oldest.
Engineers, this is the unit checkpoint. It looks like the PSSA science test: multiple choice with data, a scenario set where several questions share one situation, and short constructed responses scored 0 to 2. Read each question twice and show your reasoning.
How a 0–2 answer is scored. 2 points: a correct claim with accurate evidence or reasoning. 1 point: a correct claim with weak or missing support, or a partly correct answer. 0 points: incorrect or blank.
Worked example 1: a 2-point answer. Question: “Why is coal found in some places and not others?” Ava wrote: “Coal formed from swamp plants that were buried and squeezed for millions of years. It is only found where those swamps existed, so it is unevenly spread.” Claim plus a past process: 2 points.
Worked example 2: from 1 point to 2. Question: “A boulder’s speed doubles. How does its kinetic energy change?” “It gets bigger” earns 1 point. Diego wrote: “It becomes about four times greater, because kinetic energy depends on the square of speed.” That earns 2 points.
Scenario set data (sample data). Use this table for questions 5–7.
| Town zone | Debris flows in 40 years | Floods in 40 years | Slope | Homes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| North gully fan | 6 | 0 | steep | 40 |
| River floodplain | 0 | 5 | flat | 120 |
| Upper terrace | 0 | 0 | gentle | 60 |
| South gully fan | 1 | 0 | steep | 10 |
Rock column for question 1 (sample data). From bottom to top: Layer 1 shale with seashells; Layer 2 sandstone; Layer 3 coal; a fault cuts Layers 1–3; Layer 4 volcanic ash; Layer 5 sandstone. The fault does not cut Layer 4.
Part A: answer on your own. Your teacher reviews answers after everyone finishes.
Part B: constructed responses, each scored 0–2.
13. Use the rock column AND one other source from this unit (your road-cut notes, the class map or a reading). Explain what the seashells, coal and ash tell us about the order of past events in this valley. (0–2)
14. Using evidence from at least two sources, explain why the town's coal and groundwater are found only in certain places, and what happens to them as people use them. (0–2)
15. Sample data: debris flows followed every storm with more than 15 mm of rain in one hour on soaked ground. Write a warning rule for the town and name two technologies that would help it work. (0–2)
16. Your barrier stopped all 5 light marbles but only 3 of 5 heavy marbles from the top of the ramp. Explain the result using kinetic energy, and evaluate one change that would help, with its trade-off. (0–2)
Finished, engineers. Your results will steer the next two catch-up and stretch days.
Exit ticket: which question was hardest, and what idea do you want to practice next?
How confident are you that you can I can explain Earth's history, resources and hazards, and use kinetic energy and design evidence to protect a town.
Materials: printed checkpoint with the scenario table and rock column, scoring guide for items 13–16, calculators not needed.
Setup: about 35 minutes for Parts A and B, then a short review. Tag each item by PE: items 1–3 and 13 ESS1-4; 4 and 14 ESS3-1; 5–7, 12 and 15 ESS3-2; 8, 9 and 16 PS3-1; 10 ETS1-1; 11 and 16 ETS1-2. Use the tags to group students for 1.27 and 1.28.
Listen for: “half the speed means half the energy”; “the fault is the oldest thing”; protecting the zone with the scariest hazard instead of the one the data supports.
Support / stretch: read items aloud on request and allow the book-stack model for item 1. Stretch: rewrite item 15’s rule for a town where wildfire recently burned the slopes.