
use a weighted decision matrix to compare the three barrier concepts and make an evidence-based claim about which one to build.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Your team voted for a concept last class. Write one reason a vote might pick the wrong design for the town.
Why do engineers use a decision matrix instead of a show of hands?
Engineers, a matrix makes thinking visible. Each row is a criterion or constraint. Each column is a concept. You score each concept from 1 (poor) to 3 (strong), multiply by the row’s weight, and add the columns. The team agrees on the weights BEFORE scoring, so nobody tilts the result.
Choosing weights. Stopping boulders protects lives, so it gets weight 3. Drainage and cost each get weight 2. Ease of cleaning gets weight 1. A different class may weigh things differently, and that is fine if the reasons are stated.
| Criterion (weight) | Mesh fence | Staggered posts | Catch basin |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stops boulders (×3) | 3 → 9 | 2 → 6 | 2 → 6 |
| Drains water (×2) | 3 → 6 | 3 → 6 | 2 → 4 |
| Cost within 10 points (×2) | 2 → 4 | 2 → 4 | 3 → 6 |
| Easy to clean (×1) | 2 → 2 | 3 → 3 | 1 → 1 |
| Total | 21 | 19 | 17 |
All scores above are sample data from one imaginary team.
Worked example 1: reading the totals. Malik’s team sees the mesh fence wins with 21. He writes: “The mesh fence is the best choice because it scored highest on stopping boulders, our heaviest criterion, and it drains well. Its weakness is cleaning, which matters least.”
Worked example 2: a close call. The posts trail by only 2 points. Ava notices the posts would win if the team built a mesh-and-posts hybrid that scores 3 on stopping boulders. A matrix does not just pick a winner; it shows which weaknesses to fix next.
| Criterion (weight) | Concept 1 | Concept 2 | Concept 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stops boulders (×3) | |||
| Drains water (×2) | |||
| Cost within 10 points (×2) | |||
| Easy to clean (×1) | |||
| Total |
Use the sample matrix, then fill in your team’s own.
Score your own concepts.
Complete your team's decision matrix with agreed weights. Show every multiplication.
Write a claim about which concept your team will build. Give two strengths and one weakness from the matrix, and say how you will fix the weakness.
Your design choice now rests on evidence. Next class, you will measure how much energy a falling “boulder” really carries.
Exit ticket: would your winner change if cost had weight 3? Show your reasoning.
How confident are you that you can I can use a decision matrix to find the strengths and weaknesses of each solution.
Materials: blank matrix handouts or a shared spreadsheet, calculators, concept sketches from 1.16.
Setup: have teams agree on weights in five minutes before any scoring. Post one team’s matrix and ask the class to check every product.
Listen for: adding scores without weights; changing weights after scoring to make a favorite win.
Support / stretch: give a partly completed matrix. Stretch: test how sensitive the result is by changing one weight at a time.