
run final model tests of our breeding plan, compare the results with every criterion, and report the plan’s strengths, limits and trade-offs honestly.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Copy the four class criteria into your notebook. Next to each one, write the exact evidence you will need today to show it is met.
Which evidence shows the diversity criterion is met?
Breeders, it is Dry-Year Test Day. The farm wants proof, not promises. Every team runs its final plan (version 2) through the same test so results can be compared fairly.
The test protocol. 1. Run three bead trials of five dry generations and average them. 2. Run the spreadsheet with three weather patterns: all dry; dry, wet, dry, wet, dry; and three wet years in a row followed by two dry years. 3. Count parent lines and add up the five-season cost. 4. List every trade-off the farm should hear.
Our class criteria: (1) at least 70% of plants survive a sample dry year within 5 generations; (2) keep seed diversity, with at least 3 parent lines; (3) fit the farm’s sample budget of $300 for seed and supplies over five seasons; (4) explain any trade-offs to the farm. If your class agreed on different numbers, use yours.
Worked example 1: a test report. Diego’s team reports (sample data): “Bead trials, generation 5: 80%, 75% and 85%, average 80%. Spreadsheet: 79% in every pattern, because our dry test bed selects every year. Parent lines: 4. Cost: $130 of $300. All four criteria met.”
Worked example 2: honest about a miss. Aisha’s team kept Plan A with no donor and no test bed. In the pattern with three wet years, generation 5 reached only 57% (sample data). They write: “Our plan fails the survival criterion when wet years come first, because selection only happens in dry years. We recommend adding a test bed.” An honest miss with a clear fix is still useful to the client.
| Criterion | Target | Our result (with data) | Met? | Trade-off or limitation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dry-year survival | ≥ 70% within 5 generations | |||
| Seed diversity | ≥ 3 parent lines | |||
| Budget | ≤ $300 over 5 seasons | |||
| Trade-offs explained | Every trade-off listed |
Run the protocol, then answer.
Write your test report.
Complete the criteria table with your data. Graph generation vs survival for all three weather patterns on one set of axes.
Write a claim about how well your plan meets the criteria, with evidence from both the beads and the spreadsheet, and one limitation of the test.
Your evidence is ready. Next class, Farm Field Day: you pitch the plan to the farm.
Exit ticket: which criterion has the smallest margin, and what would you watch for in the real field?
How confident are you that you can I can test a design against criteria and report the results honestly.
Materials: bead kits from 2.21, team spreadsheets, criteria tables, graph paper.
Setup: post the three weather patterns so every team uses the same ones. Plan A in the “wet, wet, wet, dry, dry” pattern gives 45% in generation 4 and about 57% in generation 5 (sample values from the shared model).
Listen for: teams that report only the best trial; confusing a model result with a guarantee.
Support / stretch: give a test-report frame. Stretch: add a pattern with a severe drought (non-tolerant survival 0.1) and report how the margin changes.