
give and use specific, evidence-based feedback on barrier prototypes and warning plans, judged against our shared criteria.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Think of a time someone gave you feedback that really helped. What made it useful instead of hurtful?
Which feedback is the most useful to an engineering team?
Engineers, real design teams invite critique. A fresh pair of eyes spots problems the builders stopped seeing. Today every team visits two other barriers and reads their warning plans.
The protocol (20 minutes). 1. The home team demonstrates its barrier with 3 marbles and a water pour (3 min). 2. Visitors score it on the shared criteria card (3 min). 3. Visitors write one I like, one I wonder and one What if on sticky notes (3 min). 4. The home team only listens and asks questions to understand, never to defend (1 min). Then rotate.
| Shared criteria card | Met? | Evidence you saw |
|---|---|---|
| Stops at least 9 of 10 boulders from the top of a 1 m ramp | ||
| Lets water drain through | ||
| Costs no more than 10 budget points | ||
| Fits a 30 cm wide channel | ||
| Warning plan thresholds come from the data |
Worked example 1: a strong “I wonder.” Priya writes: “I wonder whether your posts will hold when debris piles up behind them, because after five marbles the third post had tilted.” It names what she saw and why it matters.
Worked example 2: a strong “What if.” Jamal writes: “What if you angled the mesh downstream like the flexible nets in the case study? It might absorb the fast marbles’ energy more slowly and stop them tearing through.” It links a science idea to a change.
Practice before the rotation.
Back with your own team.
Sort your sticky notes into “will use,” “maybe” and “won't use.” Choose the two most useful notes and explain how each would help you meet a criterion.
Compare your barrier with the best one you visited. Name one strength and one weakness of each, using the criteria card.
Feedback is fuel. Next class, you build and test version 2.
Exit ticket: write the one change you will make in version 2 and the feedback that convinced you.
How confident are you that you can I can work with others to evaluate a design using shared criteria and constraints.
Materials: version 1 barriers set up on ramps, criteria cards, three colors of sticky notes, a timer, goggles at each station.
Setup: post the rotation order. One team member stays home as the demonstrator each round, and the role rotates.
Listen for: vague praise, personal comments, and home teams defending instead of listening.
Support / stretch: give sentence starters for each note type. Stretch: write a one-paragraph summary of patterns in feedback across the class.