
gather and evaluate information from credible sources about genetic modification and gene therapy and compare their benefits and trade-offs.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Read two headlines: “Scientists Create Crop That Needs Less Water” and “Frankenfood Will Destroy Your Health!” Which source would you trust more, and what would you check first?
What is the best first step for judging a claim about gene technology?
Explore first: the source stations. Rotate through four stations. Each has a short source card about a gene technology: a university or government science page, a news article, a company advertisement and an anonymous social media post. Rate each source and record what it claims.
| Source | Who made it? | Main claim | Evidence given? | Reason to be biased? | Credibility (1–3) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | |||||
| B | |||||
| C | |||||
| D |
Name the ideas: three technologies. Artificial selection chooses parents and works with existing variation over many generations. Genetic modification (GM) means scientists add or change a specific gene in an organism to give it a trait. GM crops have been made that resist certain insects or tolerate some weed killers, and much of today’s medical insulin is made by microbes that were given the human insulin gene. Gene therapy aims to treat an inherited disease by giving a person’s cells a working version of a gene, or by fixing a faulty one. Doctors now use approved gene therapies for a small number of conditions, including an inherited form of blindness and an inherited blood disorder.
Worked example 1: weighing GM crops. Benefits: a trait can be added in fewer generations, sometimes from another species. Trade-offs: new varieties need years of safety testing and approval, seed can cost more, pollen can spread to nearby fields, and people disagree about labeling and about who controls seed. Scientific reviews have found approved GM foods as safe to eat as their non-GM versions, and testing continues.
Worked example 2: weighing gene therapy. Benefit: it can treat the cause of a disease instead of only the symptoms. Trade-offs: it can be extremely expensive, long-term effects are still being studied, and not everyone can get it. Most gene therapy changes body cells only, so it is not passed to children; changes that would be inherited raise serious ethical questions.
Cause and effect drives the technology. Each tool exists because scientists learned that genes cause traits. Knowing the cause lets people change the effect.
Use your source table and the three technologies.
Combine your sources.
Using at least two of the more credible sources, write a short summary of one gene technology: what it does, one example, one benefit and one trade-off. Name the sources you used.
Should the community farm consider a GM drought-tolerant variety, stay with selective breeding, or both? Give one reason on each side before you decide.
We have finished our investigations. Next phase, we pull the evidence together into models and explanations.
Exit ticket: choose one source from today. Explain whether it was credible, accurate and free from bias, using two pieces of evidence.
Materials: four printed source cards per station, written or adapted by the teacher from a university extension page, a government science agency page, a news article and a mock ad or post, plus credibility checklists.
Setup: make sure at least two cards are credible on each technology so students can combine sources (MS-LS4-5 asks for two reliable sources). Keep the mock ad and post clearly labeled as classroom examples.
Listen for: all-or-nothing views in either direction. Present benefits, risks and ethics with balance and respect for families’ views. Stay inside the boundary: no lab techniques or tool names. Avoid quoting prices, approval years or adoption percentages.
Support / stretch: give a sentence frame for the summary. Stretch: research how a regulator decides whether a new crop variety is safe, and report two steps in general terms.