
generate several science-based breeding plans for the community farm and compare them against the criteria and constraints.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Look back at the Wonder Board from 2.01. Move every question we can now answer to the “We know” side. Pick one and answer it in a sentence.
During a brainstorm, what should a team do with an idea that sounds unusual?
Reading: from science to plan. We now know five things. Traits vary, and some variation is inherited. Sexual reproduction makes new combinations; cuttings make copies. Mutations add new variations by chance. Selection, by nature or by people, makes helpful traits more common over generations. And the most helpful trait depends on the environment. Every plan idea today should use at least two of these ideas.
Brainstorm rules. Aim for quantity. Build on others’ ideas with “Yes, and…”. Sketch timelines, not just words. Judge later.
Worked example 1: a science-grounded plan. Ava proposed: each summer, stop watering one trial bed for two weeks during flowering, then save seed from the plants that stay greenest and still make pods. Science reason: the dry spell reveals which plants carry helpful inherited variation, and choosing them as parents raises those traits’ proportion each generation.
Worked example 2: protecting variation. Jamal added: cross the farm’s tasty variety with a deep-rooted variety, then select among the seedlings. Sexual reproduction mixes the two parents’ alleles, so some offspring may combine good taste with deep roots. He also keeps seed from at least 20 different parents so the population does not lose variation.
| Plan idea | Survives a dry spell | Keeps a useful harvest | Keeps the taste | Fits time and beds | Keeps variation | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1: | ||||||
| 2: | ||||||
| 3: |
Other tools. A team may include a GM drought-tolerant variety or seed from a seed bank as an option, as long as it weighs benefits, costs and the farm’s values using credible sources.
Brainstorm first, then work through these cards.
Sketch and score.
Sketch at least three breeding plans as five-year timelines. For each, write the science reason it should work, naming variation, reproduction and selection.
Score your plans in the decision table. Explain which you would test first, and how understanding cause and effect in traits lets the farm steer its crops on purpose. Cite one credible source from 2.09.
We have many science-grounded plan ideas. Next phase, teams build a full breeding plan, test it and revise it.
Exit ticket: name your team's top plan, the criterion it meets best, and how it would change the bean population over generations if the summers stay dry.
Materials: chart paper, markers, the Wonder Board, the criteria and constraints from 2.08, decision table handouts, the 2.09 source cards.
Setup: run a timed silent sketch (5 min), then a team “Yes, and” round (8 min) before scoring.
Listen for: plans that rely on mutations on demand, plans that clone one plant only, and plans with no science reason. The decision tables carry into part 2, where MS-ETS1-3 and MS-ETS1-4 are developed. The “20 parents” figure is a classroom rule of thumb, not a research standard.
Support / stretch: give a partly drawn timeline. Stretch: add a measurable target for one criterion and justify it to the class.