
compare three breeding plans for the community farm using sample data, and describe how each one uses a technology to influence inherited traits.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Remember our phenomenon: a farmer saved seeds only from bean plants that stayed green after a dry summer, and years later most of the field survived droughts. List two other ways a farm might get plants that handle dry weather better.
Which plan do you predict will get the farm to 70% dry-year survival fastest?
Breeders, welcome to the Build phase. In Part 1 you explained why offspring differ from their parents and how dry years favor some traits. Now you will design a breeding plan for the community farm. The farm grows four heirloom bean lines that taste great but wilt in droughts.
Our class criteria: (1) at least 70% of plants survive a sample dry year within 5 generations; (2) keep seed diversity, with at least 3 parent lines; (3) fit the farm’s sample budget of $300 for seed and supplies over five seasons; (4) explain any trade-offs to the farm. If your class agreed on different numbers, use yours.
Three plans, three technologies. Each plan is a way people influence which traits get passed on:
Worked example 1: reading a plan’s data. The table shows sample results from a quick paper model in which every year is dry. Priya reads Plan A: “Survival climbs from 45% to 78%. It first reaches 70% in generation 4, so it meets criterion 1. It keeps all four heirloom lines and costs $40, so it meets criteria 2 and 3.”
| Plan (sample data, every year dry) | Gen 1 | Gen 2 | Gen 3 | Gen 4 | Gen 5 | Parent lines | 5-season cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A. Select and save | 45% | 57% | 68% | 74% | 78% | 4 | $40 |
| B. Cross two varieties | 80% | 68% | 74% | 78% | 79% | 2 | $100 |
| C. Buy a modified variety | 80% | 80% | 80% | 80% | 80% | 1 | $750 |
Worked example 2: a plan that is fast but fails. Diego checks Plan C: “It hits 80% from generation 1, so criterion 1 is met. But it uses one parent line, so it fails diversity. At $150 a season it costs $750, more than double our $300 budget.” Fast is not enough; a plan must meet every criterion.
Notice the pattern. Plan B jumps to 80% in generation 1, dips to 68% in generation 2, and then climbs again. You first used Punnett squares in 2.05; in 2.18 you will use them to explain that dip.
Work with your team. Use the plan table for every question.
Organize the data in a new way.
Make a criteria checklist table with the three plans as rows and the four criteria as columns. Mark each cell met, not met or not yet known, and explain one “not yet known.”
Describe how each plan influences which traits are inherited. Use the words selection, cross and gene at least once.
Strong start, breeders. Next class, you will look at where information about these technologies comes from, and the ethics of each choice.
Exit ticket: which plan's weakness worries you most for the farm, and which criterion does it threaten?
How confident are you that you can I can compare breeding plans using data and criteria.
Materials: plan table on a poster or slide, the class criteria poster from Part 1, a few dry bean seeds of different colors to pass around in cups.
Setup: if Part 1 set different criteria, change the 70%, 3-line and $300 targets throughout this part. All plan numbers are sample data from the shared model (dry-year survival 0.8 for tolerant plants, 0.3 for non-tolerant). Plan C’s $150 a season is a sample price.
Listen for: “genetic modification and breeding are the same thing” (both change inherited traits, but modification changes a gene directly); “the highest number wins” (check every criterion).
Support / stretch: give a partly filled checklist table. Stretch: invent a fourth plan and predict its row of data.