
model a mutation as a change in instructions and explain how it can help, harm or have no effect on an organism’s traits.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Read three versions of a recipe line: “Add 2 cups of flour,” “Add 2 cupz of flour,” and “Add 2 cups of flower.” Which typo would ruin the cake, and which would not matter?
If one letter in a gene's instructions changes, the organism will most likely…
Explore first. Your team gets an instruction card for folding a paper airplane. Fold and fly the original three times. Then roll a die to pick one step and change a single word as your teacher directs, such as “top” to “bottom” or “half” to “third.” Build the “mutant” and fly it three times.
| Version | The changed word | Flight 1 (m) | Flight 2 (m) | Flight 3 (m) | Average (m) | Helped, hurt or no effect? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Original | none | |||||
| Mutant 1 | ||||||
| Mutant 2 |
Name the ideas. A gene is a set of instructions for building a protein. Proteins do much of the work in living things: some form structures like a leaf’s waxy coat, and some speed up jobs inside cells. The protein’s shape decides how well it works, and what proteins do shapes the organism’s traits. A mutation is a change in a gene. A mutation can change the protein’s shape and job, which can change a trait.
Worked example 1: three outcomes. Sample data: Lena’s original airplane averaged 6.0 m. Mutant 1 averaged 6.1 m, so that change had no real effect. Mutant 2 averaged 2.5 m, because its wings folded the wrong way: harmful. Mutant 3, with a sharper nose fold, averaged 7.8 m: helpful in calm air. The same idea holds for genes: beneficial, harmful or neutral.
Worked example 2: real organisms. In most mammals, the body stops making the protein that digests milk sugar after childhood. Many people carry a mutation that keeps it working into adulthood, which helped in groups that kept dairy animals. A mutation that leaves an animal without normal coloring can make it easier for predators to spot: harmful in the wild. Many mutations change nothing anyone can detect.
Two key facts. Mutations happen by chance, not because an organism needs them. And only mutations in the cells that make seeds, pollen, eggs or sperm can pass to offspring.
Use your airplane data and the gene → protein → trait chain.
Connect the model to living things.
Write the airplane model as a gene story. Name what stands for the gene, the protein and the trait. Then explain one way the model is like real mutations and one way it is different.
Describe a mutation in a crop plant that could be helpful in a drought but harmful in a very wet year. Explain why its effect depends on the environment.
New alleles start as chance mutations. Next time, we see what happens to different traits when a predator is hunting, generation after generation.
Exit ticket: explain how a change in a gene could make a protein work differently, and give an example of a change that is beneficial, one that is harmful and one that is neutral.
Materials: printed paper-airplane instruction cards, a prepared list of one-word swaps keyed to die rolls, scrap paper, a die, a tape measure, masking tape for a flight lane.
Setup: include at least one swap that changes nothing (a synonym) so teams see neutral outcomes. Fly in a hallway or gym if possible.
Listen for: “mutants are monsters” and “the organism mutates to adapt.” Stay inside the boundary: no protein-building steps, no named kinds of mutations and no DNA bases. The milk-sugar example is well documented; keep it general and avoid naming groups or giving percentages.
Support / stretch: give a gene → protein → trait organizer. Stretch: explain why a mutation that is harmful on its own might still spread if the environment changes.