
present our sorting line design to the recycling center and defend it with data, a model and the science of forces at a distance.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. The recycling center manager has five minutes for your team. What three things must they hear before they decide?
Which opening is strongest for a client presentation?
Sorting engineers, today you present to the client. Each team has 5 minutes to present and 2 minutes for questions. Every member speaks.
The five-part talk: (1) the problem and criteria; (2) how we compared designs and combined the best features; (3) our sorting line model and its limits; (4) the science: how the field acts on steel without touching, and the energy changes; (5) trial data and an honest recommendation.
Worked example 1: explaining the science simply. Mei: “The coil makes a magnetic field when current flows. Steel caps feel a pull across the gap and jump up. When we switch off, the field mostly disappears, gravity wins and the caps drop into the bin. Aluminum doesn’t feel that pull, so it rides on.”
Worked example 2: an honest recommendation. Jamal: “We recommend a coil with many turns, a flat core end and the arm close to the belt. Our model used light bottle caps, so a full-size line needs a much stronger magnet, and we suggest testing it with real crushed cans.” Naming limits builds trust.
Rehearse with your team, then present. While others present, use the blocks to take notes.
After the showcase.
Write a one-paragraph recommendation to the recycling center: which features should their sorting line use, and why? Use evidence from at least two teams.
Design, build, model, test and present a magnetic sorting line that pulls steel cans out of a mixed recycling stream for a city recycling center. It must sort at least 9 of 10 steel cans in 60 seconds, pick up no aluminum or plastic, release the steel when switched off and run on a safe low-voltage battery. Defend your design with trial data, a model of the line and the science of forces at a distance.
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Testing and combining designs | Data from three or more designs is organized in a table and graph; the best features are chosen with evidence and combined, and trade-offs are named. |
| Modeling the solution | The model shows parts, inputs, outputs, criteria and constraints; what-if data is used to improve the design; at least two limits are explained. |
| Science of forces at a distance | Explains how the coil’s magnetic field acts on steel without contact, how turns, current and distance change the force, how gravity pulls the steel down, and how energy is stored and transferred as caps move and stop. |
| Results and communication | Trial data is compared with every criterion; the recommendation is honest and clear; every member speaks and answers questions with evidence. |
You solved a real problem for a real client, sorting engineers. Next: the unit checkpoint, then two catch-up and stretch days.
Exit ticket: which question from our Wonder Board can you now answer? Write the question and your answer.
How confident are you that you can I can defend a design to a client with data, a model and science.
Materials: final sorters and model lines, graphs and feature tables on posters or slides, rubric copies for visitors, a timer.
Setup: invite staff from a local recycling program or your school’s facilities team; a video call works if they cannot attend. Visitors can score the “Results and communication” row. Run one live demo per team.
Listen for: “the magnet attracts all metal” (only iron-containing metals like steel); talks that skip limits; one student doing all the talking.
Support / stretch: give the five-part talk frame and allow note cards. Stretch: ask teams how they would add an aluminum station to the line.