
define measurable criteria and realistic constraints for the flameless meal warmer that reflect our clients’ needs, safety and the environment.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Read two client messages. The hiking club writes: “Light, small, and hot food in about ten minutes.” The preparedness group writes: “Safe for kids, works after months in a closet, no fumes indoors.” Underline every need you can measure.
Which of these is a constraint, not a criterion?
Explore first. In teams, sort the client needs onto two charts: Criteria (what the warmer must do) and Constraints (the limits it must respect). For each, write how we would measure or check it.
| Need from client | Criterion or constraint? | How we will measure or check it | Target (with units) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Food gets hot | |||
| Food gets hot quickly | |||
| Food stays warm | |||
| Safe to hold | |||
| Light to carry | |||
| Uses only safe materials | |||
| Low cost and little waste |
Name the ideas. Criteria are the requirements a successful design must meet. Constraints are the limits on a design: time, materials, cost, safety and effects on people and the environment. For a chemical warmer, good criteria focus on three measurable things: the amount of substance, the time it works, and the temperature it reaches.
Worked example 1: vague to precise. “Gets hot” is vague. Our class proposes, as a starting point, “raises 100 g of water at least 15°C above room temperature within 10 minutes, and keeps it at least 10°C above its start for 20 minutes.” That target has a mass, a temperature change and a time, so we can test it. We use water as a safe stand-in for food.
Worked example 2: a constraint with reasons. Diego wrote, “Use only processes on the teacher’s approved list, with no more than 20 g of heater material.” The reasons: safety, cost and carrying weight. He added, “Nothing that releases a flammable gas,” because the pouch may be used indoors during a power outage.
Thinking beyond the user. Single-use heaters create trash. If we do not solve the problem at all, people might cook over open flames in unsafe places. Good constraints weigh both risks.
Use your team’s sorting charts. Discuss each card first.
Write your team’s design brief.
Write three criteria and three constraints for the warmer. Each criterion needs a target with units. Each constraint needs a reason.
Explain one way a used warmer could affect the environment, and one risk of not solving the problem at all.
We now have a clear, testable problem. Next phase, we make sense of our data with models and an argument, and start brainstorming designs.
Exit ticket: restate the warmer problem in one sentence. Then write the criterion you think matters most, with a target and units.
Materials: client message cards, sticky notes in two colors, chart paper labeled Criteria and Constraints.
Setup: post the class-agreed criteria and constraints at the end; they guide part 2’s Build and Prove It phases. The 15°C rise, 10-minute and 20 g values are classroom starting points, not industry standards; let classes adjust them with reasons.
Listen for: students mixing criteria and constraints, and criteria with no units. Keep MS-PS1-6 criteria to amount, time and temperature.
Support / stretch: provide a sentence frame: “The warmer must ___ (target with units) because ___.” Stretch: rank the criteria and explain which trade-off you would accept.