
build three electromagnet sorters that differ in one factor and use data to predict which will pull steel the hardest.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Remember the scrapyard crane from our phenomenon. It lifts a whole car, then drops it when the operator flips a switch. Which part of that magnet must be different from a fridge magnet?
Why can a scrapyard crane drop a car on command?
Sorting engineers, welcome to the Build phase. Our client, a city recycling center, needs a sorting line that pulls steel cans out of a mixed stream. In class, steel bottle caps or washers stand in for the cans. Aluminum foil pieces and plastic beads stand in for everything else.
Our criteria: sort at least 9 of 10 steel “cans” out of a mixed batch in 60 seconds, pick up no aluminum or plastic, and release the steel when switched off. Our constraint: a safe, low-voltage battery, with short contact only.
An electromagnet is a coil of wire around an iron or steel core. When current flows through the coil, the core becomes a magnet. When the current stops, most of the magnetism goes away. That on-off switch is exactly what a sorter needs.
Three factors you can change. In Part 1 you found that more turns of wire, more current and a smaller distance all make the magnetic force stronger. Today each team builds three versions that change just one factor, so the test is fair.
Worked example 1: turning a pattern into a hypothesis. Jamal’s team tested two coils on one cell (sample data). The 20-turn coil picked up 4 steel caps. The 40-turn coil picked up 8. Their hypothesis: “If we use 60 turns, then the coil will pick up about 12 caps, because more turns made a stronger magnetic force in our data.” Doubling the turns roughly doubled the pickups here, but they will test whether the pattern keeps going.
Worked example 2: distance matters. Mei held the same coil at three heights above a tray of caps (sample data). At 0.5 cm it lifted 6 caps. At 1 cm it lifted 2. At 2 cm it lifted none. Her claim: the magnetic force gets weaker quickly as distance grows. So a sorter must pass close to the stream.
| Version | Turns | Cells (1.5 V each) | Core | Caps lifted at 0.5 cm | Our prediction |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | |||||
| B | |||||
| C |
Build Version A first, then change ONE factor for B and C. Record each result in the table before you move on.
Use your team’s table.
Write a hypothesis for your Version C, using If… then… because…. Your because must cite data from Version A or B.
Mei's data showed 6 caps at 0.5 cm and 2 caps at 1 cm. Predict how many caps lift at 1.5 cm, and explain the pattern you used.
Three sorters built, sorting engineers. Next class we run real sorting trials and time them.
Exit ticket: name the two factors that most changed the strength of your electromagnet. Give the evidence for each.
How confident are you that you can I can use data to predict how strong an electromagnet will be when I change one factor.
Materials (per team): about 3 m of enameled magnet wire (22–26 gauge), three large iron nails or steel bolts, sandpaper, one or two D-cell holders and cells, 20 steel bottle caps or small steel washers, a ruler, goggles. Test every “steel cap” with a magnet first; some caps are aluminum.
Setup: post the class criteria and constraints from 2.09. If your class set different targets, use yours everywhere this part says 9 of 10 or 60 seconds. Sand 2 cm of enamel off each wire end before class for younger groups. Wind turns tightly in one direction. The 0.5 cm test height can be set with a stack of index cards.
Listen for: “the battery is the magnet” (the current in the coil makes the magnetism); changing two factors at once; treating sample patterns as exact laws.
Support / stretch: give a prewritten hypothesis frame. Stretch: test a steel nail core versus a pencil (no core) at the same turns and explain the difference.