
run timed sorting trials on three designs, organize the data in a table and graph, and show that the force comes from the coil.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Sorter A picked up 9 steel caps and 1 foil piece. Sorter B picked up 7 steel caps and nothing else. Which is better for the recycling center? Be ready to defend your choice.
Which sorter meets our criterion “picks up no aluminum or plastic”?
Sorting engineers, a recycling center cares about two numbers. Rate is how many steel cans are sorted per minute. Accuracy is how many of the sorted items are really steel. A fast sorter that grabs trash is not useful, and neither is a perfect sorter that takes all day.
The trial. Mix 10 steel caps, 5 foil pieces and 5 plastic beads in a tray. Start the timer. Switch the sorter on, sweep it over the tray at about 0.5 cm, move to the steel bin and switch it off. Repeat until 60 seconds pass. Run three trials per design and find the mean.
Worked example 1: organizing the data. Priya’s team tested three designs (sample data). They found each mean from three trials.
| Design | Steel sorted in 60 s (mean of 3) | Wrong items picked | Released when off? |
|---|---|---|---|
| A: 20 turns, 1 cell | 5 | 0 | Yes |
| B: 40 turns, 1 cell | 8 | 0 | Yes |
| C: 40 turns, 2 cells | 10 | 1 (foil stuck to a cap) | Mostly; 1 cap stuck |
A bar graph of “steel sorted” makes the pattern easy to see: C > B > A. But no design meets every criterion yet.
Worked example 2: proving the coil causes the force. Malik switched Design B off while it held 8 caps. Most caps dropped at once. Then he pulled the battery out completely and tried again. Nothing lifted. When the second object (the current-carrying coil) is removed or turned off, the force disappears. That is evidence that the coil acts on the caps without touching them.
| Design | Trial 1 | Trial 2 | Trial 3 | Mean steel sorted | Wrong items | Released? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | ||||||
| B | ||||||
| C |
Rotate roles each trial: Timer, Sorter, Counter and Recorder.
Use your own team’s data.
Make a bar graph of your mean steel sorted for each design. Mark the criterion line at 9. Which designs cross it?
Describe the observation that shows the steel caps were pulled by the coil without touching it. What happened when the coil was switched off?
Data organized, sorting engineers. Next class we look for the best feature of each design and combine them.
Exit ticket: which design had the best rate, and which had the best accuracy? Are they the same design?
How confident are you that you can I can organize test data from three designs in a table and a graph.
Materials: the three sorters from 2.15, trays, 10 steel caps + 5 foil pieces + 5 plastic beads per tray, timers, two bins per team, graph paper.
Setup: keep the foil pieces small and flat. Remind teams that the 60-second rule includes moving to the bin. Short contact still applies: switch off between sweeps.
Listen for: “foil is magnetic” (foil sometimes rides along stuck to a cap, or clings by static; it is not pulled by the magnet); means calculated by adding only.
Support / stretch: give a partly filled table and a labeled graph frame. Stretch: compute each design’s accuracy as a fraction (steel sorted ÷ all items picked).