
use amount, time and temperature data to choose a process for the warmer and explain how it will release thermal energy to the food.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. An iron hand warmer stays warm for hours. Calcium chloride heats water within a minute or two. Which would you rather use to warm a meal on a cold trail? Write one reason.
You double the calcium chloride in the same amount of water. What happens to the temperature rise?
Reading: choosing a process. Engineers pick a heat source by comparing data, not by guessing. For our warmer, three questions matter. How much substance does it need? How quickly does it heat? How hot does it get, and for how long? Those are the criteria of amount, time and temperature.
| Calcium chloride in 50 mL water (g) | Sample temperature rise (°C) | Time to highest temperature (s) | Meets our 15°C target? |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | 10 | 60 | |
| 10 | 19 | 75 | |
| 15 | 27 | 90 | |
| 20 | 34 | 90 |
Worked example 1: reading the table. These are sample data. From 5 g to 10 g, the rise nearly doubles, from 10°C to 19°C. The pattern suggests more substance releases more energy into the water. Note that this rise is for the 50 mL of activating water only; the food will warm less, because energy spreads into a larger mass and leaks into the air.
Worked example 2: matching the process to the need. Priya compared three options. Calcium chloride heats fast but briefly. An iron-powder warmer heats slowly for hours, too slow for a quick meal. Baking soda with citric acid absorbs energy, so it would cool the food. Priya chose calcium chloride for heating and an insulating sleeve to hold the energy in.
What real meal heaters use. Many commercial flameless meal heaters contain magnesium mixed with iron and salt. Adding water starts a reaction that releases a lot of thermal energy and also gives off hydrogen gas, which is flammable. That is one reason their packages carry safety warnings. We describe these heaters only; we never make or open them in class.
Use the sample data table and the 1.07 results. Discuss each card first.
Make and defend your choice.
Choose a heat source for the warmer. Explain how it releases thermal energy, how much you would use and why, using the sample data.
Name two limits on your choice, such as safety, cost or the 20 g constraint, and explain how each shapes the design.
We have a heat source and a reason for it. Next time, we read pilot test data and decide what works best.
Exit ticket: explain, step by step, how your heat source gets thermal energy into the meal. Name each part of the system it passes through.
Materials: the sample data table, 1.07 class data, an unopened hand warmer package to pass around (do not open).
Setup: replace the sample data with your own class data if you ran a dose test in 1.07. Real values depend on the product’s form and purity.
Listen for: “more is always better.” Bring in constraints: cost, mass and safety. Keep commercial magnesium heaters description only; never demonstrate or have students handle them. Do not quote heating times or temperatures for commercial heaters.
Support / stretch: highlight one row at a time in the table. Stretch: predict the rise for 25 g and say whether you trust the prediction, and why.