
generate several warmer designs grounded in the science and compare them against our criteria and constraints.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Look back at the Wonder Board from 1.01. Move every question we can now answer to the “We know” side. Pick one and answer it in a sentence.
During a brainstorm, what should a team do with an idea that sounds unusual?
Reading: from science to design. We now know four things. Some processes release thermal energy and some absorb it. More heater material releases more energy. Energy flows from warmer to cooler matter, and a larger mass warms less. Insulators slow energy leaving, and conductors speed it along. Every design idea today should use at least one of these ideas.
Brainstorm rules. Aim for quantity. Build on others’ ideas with “Yes, and…”. Sketch, do not just write. Judge later.
Worked example 1: a science-grounded idea. Mei sketched a “sandwich” pouch: the heater bag between two flat food pouches. Science reason: the heater touches more food surface, so more energy flows into the food instead of the air. She labeled a foam outer layer to minimize loss and keep the outside comfortable.
Worked example 2: comparing ideas with a decision table. Malik scored two ideas from 1 to 3 on each criterion. The sandwich pouch scored 3 for heating speed and 2 for weight. A thick wool wrap scored 2 for heating and 1 for weight. The table makes trade-offs visible, so the team can choose with reasons.
| Idea | 15°C rise in 10 min | Stays warm 20 min | Safe to hold | Within 20 g | Light and low waste | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1: | ||||||
| 2: | ||||||
| 3: |
Who else is affected? Score at least one idea for its effect on the environment, such as reusable sleeves versus throw-away wraps.
Brainstorm first, then work through these cards with your team.
Sketch and score.
Sketch at least three warmer designs. Label the heat source, the food, the insulating layers and energy arrows. Write the science reason behind each design.
Score your three designs in the decision table. Explain which you would prototype first, and name one constraint that shaped your choice.
We have many science-grounded ideas. Next phase, teams build prototypes, test them and revise.
Exit ticket: name your team's top design, the criterion it meets best and the constraint you worry about most.
Materials: chart paper, markers, the Wonder Board, the class criteria and constraints from 1.09, decision table handouts.
Setup: run a timed silent sketch (5 min), then a team “Yes, and” round (8 min) before scoring.
Listen for: designs that ignore safety or exceed 20 g, and ideas with no science reason. The decision tables carry into part 2’s prototype lessons, where MS-ETS1-2 is developed formally.
Support / stretch: give a partly drawn pouch template. Stretch: add a criterion of your own with a measurable target and justify it to the class.