
pitch my warmer to the hiking club and the preparedness group, and defend it with test data, chemistry and a decision matrix.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. The hiking club and the preparedness group give each team five minutes. What three things do they most need to hear?
Which opening best fits our clients?
Engineers, today the clients are here. Members of a hiking club and a community preparedness group visit in person or by video. They will decide which design ideas to share with their members.
Your five-minute pitch. 1. The problem, who it affects and the system. 2. Your concepts and decision matrix. 3. How your warmer works: the process that releases thermal energy, and how insulation keeps it in the meal. 4. Trail Test Day data against every criterion. 5. Safety, waste and your honest recommendation.
Worked example 1: the science, simply. Mei said: “When calcium chloride dissolves in water, it releases thermal energy. That energy flows from the hot pack into the cooler meal. Our foam sleeve slows energy escaping to cold air, so more of it stays in your food.” Short, accurate and tied to the design.
Worked example 2: honest trade-offs. Diego said: “Our warmer met every criterion in class, but at the cold station it rose 15 °C by 10 minutes, just enough. The pack is single-use, so hikers must carry it out. Military heaters work faster, but they release hydrogen gas, so we chose a safer process.” Clients trust honest data.
Rehearse with your team before the clients arrive.
After all the pitches, reflect.
What did a client ask or suggest? Name one idea from another team that you would borrow, and explain why.
Write a one-paragraph recommendation to the hiking club: which design should they share, and why? Use evidence from at least two teams.
Design, build, test and pitch a flameless meal warmer for a hiking club and a community emergency-preparedness group. It must raise a 100 g meal at least 15 °C within 10 minutes and keep it at least 10 °C above its start at 20 minutes, using no more than 20 g of heater material, no flame or electricity, no leaks, and an outside that is safe to hold. Defend it with a decision matrix, an energy-flow model and Trail Test Day data.
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Defining the problem | The problem, the people affected, the system and measurable criteria and constraints (temperature rise, time, the 20 g limit, safety, no flame, waste) are stated clearly. |
| Evaluating designs | Competing concepts are scored in a weighted decision matrix; the claim names strengths, weaknesses and evidence, and uses what existing heaters show. |
| Science of reactions and energy | The pitch explains that dissolving calcium chloride releases thermal energy, that energy flows from warmer to cooler, and how insulation, mass and materials affect the meal’s temperature change; property evidence separates dissolving from a reaction. |
| Testing and communication | Trail Test data is graphed and compared with every criterion; one limitation is named; every member speaks; the recommendation is honest and clear. |
You solved a real problem for real people, engineers. Next: the unit checkpoint, then two catch-up and stretch days.
Exit ticket: which question from our Wonder Board can you now answer? Write the question and your answer.
How confident are you that you can I can defend a design to a client with data and science.
Materials: final warmers (unactivated, or used packs sealed in a second bag), graphs and matrices on posters or slides, rubric copies for visitors, timer.
Setup: invite members of a local hiking or outdoor club and a community emergency-preparedness volunteer group, or staff who can role-play them; a video call works. Visitors can score the “Testing and communication” row. Do not activate packs during pitches.
Listen for: talks that skip the data; “the pack makes heat from nothing”; one student doing all the talking.
Support / stretch: give a five-box pitch frame and allow note cards. Stretch: propose a reusable version and explain its trade-offs.