
use electromagnet data to write a hypothesis and a claim about how coil turns and current change magnetic force.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Look at this sample class data for a 30-turn electromagnet: 1 cell lifted 8 clips; 2 cells lifted 15 clips. Write one thing you notice and one thing you wonder.
Using the sample pattern, what would 60 turns with 2 cells most likely do?
Pooling the class data. Each team adds its averages to the class table. Pooled data from many teams is more reliable than one team’s results.
| Turns | Cells | Team averages (clips) | Class average (clips) | Pattern you notice |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10 | 1 | |||
| 20 | 1 | |||
| 40 | 1 | |||
| 30 | 1 | |||
| 30 | 2 |
Worked example 1: proportional reasoning. In the 2.05 sample data, 10 turns lifted 3 clips and 20 turns lifted 6. Twice the turns, about twice the clips. From 20 to 40 turns the clips went from 6 to 11, a little less than double. The pattern is roughly proportional at first and may level off.
Worked example 2: a model CER. Question: “How does the number of turns affect an electromagnet’s strength?”
Sentence starters. Claim: “Increasing ___ makes the electromagnet ___.” Evidence: “When we changed ___ from ___ to ___, the clips changed from ___ to ___.” Reasoning: “This happens because ___.”
Why it matters for the client. A scrapyard crane is an electromagnet that operators switch on and off. Our sorting line can work the same way: on to grab steel, off to drop it in the bin.
Use the class table. Discuss each card before you write your CER.
Predict outcomes from your hypothesis.
Using your hypothesis, predict three outcomes: (a) more turns, same current; (b) same turns, less current; (c) the current switched off. Explain how each change leads to a different outcome.
How confident are you that you can I can use data to make a hypothesis about electromagnet strength.
Our data supports a clear rule of thumb: more turns and more current, stronger magnet. Next time, we build an argument about gravity.
Exit ticket: write one testable question the class data has not yet answered about electromagnets. Name what you would change and measure.
Materials: class data table on the board or a shared sheet, teams’ 2.05 data, graph paper, CER organizer.
Setup: collect team averages at the start. If teams’ data conflict, use that to talk about reliability and repeat trials.
Listen for: claims with no numbers, or evidence that changes two variables at once. All worked-example numbers are sample data. Proportional reasoning is fine; no formulas for magnetic force (MS-PS2-3 boundary).
Support / stretch: give a CER with the claim filled in. Stretch: explain why the class average may level off at high turns, using what they know about batteries running down.