
give and use peer feedback on a hybrid lander, explain how each part works, and name where our drop test model falls short of a real Moon landing.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Our test drops the lander 2 meters onto a classroom floor. A real lander falls toward the Moon. List two ways the real situation is different from our test.
Which is a real difference between our test and a Moon landing?
Mission engineers, critique makes designs stronger. Today each team presents its hybrid sketch or early build. Another team gives feedback with our protocol: “I like … I wonder … What if …” Feedback is about the design, never the person.
Explain every part. A strong presenter explains what each part does and how it connects to the problem. For example: “The crumple base lets the lander stop over a longer distance. That keeps the payload’s force pair small, which meets the no-crack criterion.”
Every model has limits. Our drop test is a model of a Moon landing. It is useful, but it is not the real thing. Naming limits is part of good engineering, not a weakness.
Worked example 1: Priya explains her parts. “Our lander has three parts. The straw legs spread out the landing so it does not tip. The paper crumple cup crushes at impact. The cotton nest holds the egg still. Our data showed the crumple cup protects best, and the nest stops the egg from sliding.”
Worked example 2: Diego names limits. “Our model drops from 2 m on Earth. A real lander could hit the Moon much faster if its engines failed. The Moon’s gravity is weaker, and there is no air. Real landers must carry fuel, so their mass limits are much stricter. Our egg is also not as tough as real cargo. So our results show which features help, not exactly how a real lander would do.”
| I like … | I wonder … | What if … | Change we will make |
|---|---|---|---|
Practice critique and model thinking before you visit another team.
Use the feedback you received.
For each part of your hybrid, explain its job and how it connects to a criterion. Then name one change from your critique and the evidence behind it.
Name two limitations of our drop test as a model of a Moon landing. For each, say how it could change your results.
Strong designs survive good questions. Next class: a mid-build checkpoint, then we build version 2.
Exit ticket: what was the most useful piece of feedback you got, and what will you change because of it?
Materials: hybrid sketches or early builds, critique table handout, timer.
Setup: pair teams. Use 4 minutes to present, 4 minutes of feedback, then switch. Rotate once more if time allows.
Listen for: vague feedback (“it’s good”); redirect to the data. Also listen for “there’s no gravity on the Moon”; the Moon’s gravity is weaker than Earth’s, not zero.
Support / stretch: provide sentence starters on table tents. Stretch: suggest a change to the test itself that would make it a better model of a Moon landing.