
give and use kind, specific, evidence-based feedback to find each cooler’s strengths and weaknesses.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Which feedback is more useful: “It’s bad” or “Your lid has a gap, and your temperature rose fastest after 20 minutes”? Why?
Good feedback in a design critique is…
Design engineers, critique makes designs better. Real engineering teams review each other’s work often. Today, each team presents version 1 and its data. Two visiting teams give feedback using three stems.
The protocol (6 minutes per round). 1. The design team shares its cooler, matrix and data log in 90 seconds. 2. Visitors ask clarifying questions. 3. Visitors give feedback: I like… (a strength), I wonder… (a question), What if… (an idea). 4. The design team thanks them and writes everything down without arguing.
Use the shared criteria. Everyone critiques with the same criteria and constraints. That keeps it fair. Visitors score each cooler on the critique matrix below.
Worked example 1: Priya visits Diego’s Wool Wrap. “I like that it weighs only 300 g, so it is easy to carry. I wonder why the temperature jumped between 20 and 30 minutes. What if you added a foil layer to reflect energy and a tighter drawstring?” Each part names evidence or a criterion.
Worked example 2: turning feedback into a claim. Diego’s team wrote: “Our strength is weight. Our weakness is the opening, where warm air gets in. Fixing the opening should help us meet the 4 °C criterion, because less fast-moving air will enter.”
| Team visited | Keeps cold (1–3) | Cost (1–3) | Carry (1–3) | Environment (1–3) | I like / I wonder / What if |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Practice the protocol before the real rounds.
After two rounds, sort the feedback.
List your cooler's two biggest strengths and two biggest weaknesses, using your critique matrix scores and test data.
Make a claim: which ONE change will improve your cooler most? Support it with evidence and a particle-based reason.
Great critique, design engineers. Next class you revise and run the heat test again.
Exit ticket: write the best piece of feedback you received and who gave it. How will you use it?
How confident are you that you can I can evaluate designs with shared criteria and use evidence to pick the best change.
Materials: version 1 coolers, data logs and graphs, critique matrices, sticky notes in three colors for the three stems.
Setup: two 6-minute rounds, with a timer. Pair teams so different designs visit each other. Use 1.20 results to seat a strong explainer in each group.
Listen for: feedback about looks only; teams defending rather than recording. Prompt: “What does the data say?”
Support / stretch: provide stem cards with blanks. Stretch: ask visitors to predict the new temperature rise if their What if idea were used.