
present our cooler to the field trip team and defend it with test data, particle science and a decision matrix.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. The field trip team has five minutes per team. What three things do they most need to hear?
Which opening best fits our client?
Design engineers, today the client is here. Members of the 6th-grade field trip team, such as teachers, chaperones and a front office helper, visit in person or by video. They will choose which designs to copy for the next trip.
Your five-minute showcase. 1. The problem and who it affects. 2. Your concepts and decision matrix. 3. Your final cooler and how it works, with a particle model. 4. Your test data from field trip day. 5. Materials: where they come from and their effect on the environment.
Worked example 1: explaining the science simply. Mei said: “Warm air outside has fast-moving particles. Our foam walls are full of trapped air, so energy passes through slowly. The ice absorbs what gets in and melts slowly, which keeps the lunch at 3.5 °C.” Short, accurate and tied to the design.
Worked example 2: being honest about trade-offs. Diego said: “Our wool cooler kept lunch at 4.0 °C, just meeting the criterion. It costs $4.50, more than foam. But wool is a natural, reusable material, and foam is hard to recycle. If you want the coldest cooler, pick foam. If you want less waste, pick wool.” Clients trust honest data.
Rehearse with your team before the client arrives.
After all presentations, reflect.
What did the client ask or suggest? Name one idea from another team that you would borrow, and explain why.
Write a one-paragraph recommendation to the field trip team: which design should they copy, and why? Use evidence from at least two teams.
Design, build, test and present a cooler that keeps a packed lunch at 4 °C or colder from 7:30 until 12:30, with no electricity, for the 6th-grade field trip team. Defend your design with a decision matrix, a particle model and field-trip-day data, and explain where your materials come from.
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Defining the problem | The problem, the people affected, the system, measurable criteria and constraints (cost, time, safety, environment) are stated clearly. |
| Evaluating designs | Two or more concepts are scored in a weighted decision matrix; the claim about the best design names strengths, weaknesses and evidence, and uses ideas from how others solved similar problems. |
| Science of matter and energy | A particle model shows the cooler system and explains how slowing thermal energy keeps the ice solid and the lunch cold; temperature and thermal energy are used correctly; materials are traced to natural or synthetic sources. |
| Testing and communication | Field-trip-day data is graphed and compared with every criterion; one limitation is named; every member speaks; the recommendation to the client is honest and clear. |
You solved a real problem for real people, design engineers. Next: the unit checkpoint, then two catch-up and stretch days.
Exit ticket: which question from our Wonder Board can you now answer? Write the question and your answer.
How confident are you that you can I can defend a design to a client with data and science.
Materials: final coolers, graphs and matrices on posters or slides, rubric copies for visitors, a timer.
Setup: invite the teachers and chaperones planning a grade-level trip; a video call works if they cannot attend. Visitors can score the “Testing and communication” row. Score the rubric during talks.
Listen for: talks that skip the data; “keeps the cold in” language; one student doing all the talking.
Support / stretch: give a five-box presentation frame and allow note cards. Stretch: ask teams to estimate how their cooler would do on a much hotter day and why.