
combine information from text, diagrams and graphs to explain how synthetic materials are made and how they affect resources, society and the environment.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. A foam cooler is light, cheap and keeps food cold. Some cities and states have limited foam food containers. List one reason a community might do that.
What is the biggest trade-off with single-use foam?
Gallery walk. Visit four stations. Station A is a short article on how plastics are made from oil and gas. Station B is a flow diagram from oil well to finished product. Station C is a graph your teacher made from class insulation data. Station D compares a foam cooler, a hard plastic cooler and a cloth lunch bag.
| Station | Type of source (text, diagram, graph) | Key fact | Credible? Why or why not? | Effect on people or the environment |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | ||||
| B | ||||
| C | ||||
| D |
Worked example 1: combining sources. Jamal used the diagram to show the steps: oil and gas, then separated chemicals, then polymers, then foam. He used the article to explain that chemical reactions build the polymers. He used the class graph to show foam’s insulating property. Three sources together told a fuller story than any one alone.
Worked example 2: does the evidence support the claim? Priya read the claim, “Synthetic materials are made from natural resources by chemical processes.” Her diagram showed oil becoming new substances with new properties. She decided her sources supported the claim. She also noted that society benefits, through safer food storage and many medicines, and pays costs, through resource use and waste.
Back to our constraints. These effects belong in our design brief. A cooler that uses less new plastic, lasts many trips or reuses materials reduces harm. Not solving the problem also has costs: spoiled food is wasted food.
Use your station notes. Name the station for each answer.
Write a short source-based explanation.
Using at least two stations, explain how a foam cooler is made from natural resources, one way it helps society and one way it harms the environment. Cite each station.
Add one new environmental constraint to our design brief, based on today's sources.
Synthetic materials bring real benefits and real costs. Next time, we use everything we have learned to brainstorm cooler designs.
Exit ticket: should our class cooler use new foam, reused foam or a different material? Give one piece of evidence from today.
Materials: four station posters. Write the article and flow diagram yourself from a reliable reference; build the graph from your class’s 1.06 data; Station D is a simple comparison chart you make from the three products.
Setup: 6 minutes per station, then a team synthesis. Keep facts general: limits on foam containers exist in some U.S. cities and states, and many recycling programs do not take foam. Do not cite numbers you cannot verify.
Listen for: “all plastic is bad” or “synthetic materials have no downsides.” Push for both benefits and costs. Formal design evaluation (decision matrix, MS-ETS1-2) waits for part 2.
Support / stretch: provide a two-column benefits and costs organizer. Stretch: research a plant-based plastic and compare its natural resource with foam’s.