
test our final cooler through a full field-trip morning and judge it against every criterion and constraint using data.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Today is our pretend field trip. Lunches are packed at 7:30 and eaten at 12:30. How many minutes is that? How many 30-minute readings will we take?
From 7:30 to 12:30, with a reading every 30 minutes (including 7:30), how many readings are there?
Design engineers, this is the real test. Our client asked for lunches that stay safe until 12:30. Today we run the whole morning, not 40 minutes. Each class period that meets in this room takes readings, so the data log follows the cooler all morning.
Setup. At 7:30, each cooler gets a fresh 200 g ice bag and a fridge-cold lunch bottle. Coolers sit in the warmest safe spot we have, like a sunny window, to act like a bus or picnic table. A sealed, half-empty plastic bottle of air sits next to each cooler as a “pressure check.” At 12:30 we open the lid, measure the lunch bottle and weigh the meltwater.
Worked example 1: judging against criteria. These are sample numbers. Team Priya’s lunch read 3.5 °C at 12:30 and 70 g of the 200 g ice melted, so 130 g stayed frozen. Criterion 1, 4 °C or colder: met. Criterion 2, half the ice still frozen: met, since 130 g is more than 100 g. Cost $4.50 and 650 g to carry: constraints met.
Worked example 2: the pressure check. By 12:30, the sealed bottle in the sunny window felt firm and its sides bulged slightly. Jamal explained: “The air inside got warmer. Its particles moved faster and hit the walls harder and more often, so the pressure went up.” A cold bottle from the fridge looks the opposite: its sides pull in a little.
| Time | Inside temp (°C) | Room or window temp (°C) | Reader |
|---|---|---|---|
| 7:30 | |||
| 8:00 | |||
| 8:30 | |||
| 9:00 | |||
| 9:30 | |||
| 10:00 | |||
| 10:30 | |||
| 11:00 | |||
| 11:30 | |||
| 12:00 | |||
| 12:30 (lunch bottle + meltwater) |
| Criterion or constraint | Target | Our result | Met? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lunch temperature at 12:30 | 4 °C or colder | ||
| Ice still frozen | 100 g or more | ||
| Holds lunch and drink | yes | ||
| Cost | $5 or less | ||
| Easy to carry, reusable | yes |
Answer these as the readings come in.
Write your test report.
Graph your morning data. Complete the criteria table. Did your cooler pass? Support your claim with at least three numbers.
Name one limitation of today's test. How might it make the results different from a real field trip?
You have the evidence. Next class you present your cooler to the field trip team.
Exit ticket: if your cooler failed a criterion, what ONE change would you make? If it passed, what would make it even better?
How confident are you that you can I can evaluate a design against criteria and constraints using test data.
Materials: final coolers, fresh 200 g ice bags, fridge lunch bottles, probe thermometers, sealed half-empty bottles, a shared data sheet by the coolers, scale or measuring cup.
Setup: pack at 7:30 (or at first period). Ask colleagues who use the room to have a student take each reading; or take readings yourself. If the schedule makes this hard, run a compressed test with a smaller ice bag and say so as a limitation.
Listen for: “pressure rose because air got in” (the bottle is sealed); passing a cooler on looks rather than data.
Support / stretch: pre-draw graph axes. Stretch: plot the window temperature too, and describe how the gap between inside and outside changed.