
use a weighted decision matrix to compare cooler concepts and make an evidence-based claim about which one to build.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Priya’s team says, “Let’s build the Foam Fortress because it looks the coolest.” What is missing from her reason?
What should a team's choice of design be based on?
Design engineers, a decision matrix is a scoring table. Each row is a criterion or constraint. Each column is a concept. You score every concept on every row, then add up the totals. It is a systematic method: everyone uses the same rules.
Step 1: agree on the rows and weights as a team. Some criteria matter more than others. Food safety is the most important, so it gets a weight of 3. Cost gets 2. Carrying ease and environmental impact each get 1. Your team must agree on these before scoring.
Step 2: score each concept from 1 (weak) to 3 (strong). Use evidence from Investigate, such as which materials slowed ice melting best. Then multiply each score by its weight.
Worked example 1: scoring two concepts. Mei’s team scored the Foam Fortress and the Wool Wrap.
| Row (weight) | Foam Fortress score × weight | Wool Wrap score × weight |
|---|---|---|
| Keeps lunch cold (×3) | 3 × 3 = 9 | 2 × 3 = 6 |
| Cost under $5 (×2) | 3 × 2 = 6 | 2 × 2 = 4 |
| Easy to carry (×1) | 2 × 1 = 2 | 3 × 1 = 3 |
| Environmental impact (×1) | 1 × 1 = 1 | 3 × 1 = 3 |
| Total | 18 | 16 |
Worked example 2: the claim. Mei wrote: “We claim the Foam Fortress is the better design. It scored 18 to 16, mostly because foam slowed ice melting best in our tests. Its weakness is environmental impact, since foam is hard to recycle. We will borrow the wool idea for a reusable lid.” She named strengths, a weakness and evidence. The matrix supports a decision; it does not end the thinking.
Your turn. Build your own matrix below for your concepts.
| Row (weight) | Concept A | Concept B | Concept C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Keeps lunch cold (×3) | |||
| Cost under $5 (×2) | |||
| Easy to carry (×1) | |||
| Environmental impact (×1) | |||
| Total |
Use the worked example table to answer these, then score your own concepts.
Make your claim.
Complete your team's matrix. Then write a claim: which concept will you build? Give the totals as evidence, and name one strength and one weakness of your choice.
Name one idea from a losing concept that you could combine into your winner. Explain why it helps.
Your team has a plan backed by evidence. Next class, we learn how real engineers keep medicines and food cold across long trips.
Exit ticket: why is a decision matrix fairer than a vote on which sketch looks best?
How confident are you that you can I can use a decision matrix to compare designs against criteria and constraints.
Materials: notebooks, calculators, concept sketches from 1.15, Investigate data on ice melting by material.
Setup: model the weighted math once on the board. Teams may change the weights, but they must agree before scoring and explain the change.
Listen for: teams adjusting scores after seeing totals to make a favorite win; adding scores without multiplying by weights.
Support / stretch: provide a matrix with weights filled in. Stretch: score on a 1–5 scale and see whether the winner changes.