
use what I know about rain and erosion to write what our solution must do and what limits it must stay inside.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. The council has a small budget. Your team wants a big stone wall on every hill. Is that a good plan? Talk for one minute.
If a town can only pay for a little, what should engineers do?
Junior engineers, a great design starts with a clear goal. Before we improve our prototypes, we sharpen the design brief. A design brief lists the criteria and the constraints.
Criteria use science. We learned that steep slopes and fast water carry more soil. So a strong criterion is: “Keep the mud rating at 2 or less on the steep hill.” That is a goal we can measure. It also comes from our data, not a guess.
Constraints are limits. Common limits are cost, materials, time and space. A solution must also work in different situations, like a light rain and a big storm.
Worked example 1: a measurable criterion. Jamal writes, “The road should be safer.” That is hard to test. Mei rewrites it: “After one cup of water, the road stays dry.” Now the team can test it with a yes or no.
Worked example 2: a budget. In our class store, each team has 10 points. Craft sticks cost 1 point. A sponge costs 3 points. Clay costs 2 points. Diego’s team wants a wall and a rain garden. That costs 5 points, so it fits. They save the rest for repairs after testing.
Benefits and risks. A good plan raises benefits, like safer homes. It also lowers risks and costs. And it meets what people need, like a road that stays open.
Fill in your team’s design brief. Use your data from the investigations and your first prototype test.
| Part of the brief | What we wrote | Which data or science supports it? |
|---|---|---|
| Criterion 1 (soil) | ||
| Criterion 2 (water / road) | ||
| Constraint 1 (cost) | ||
| Constraint 2 (materials, time or space) |
Plan your spending.
You have 10 points. Craft sticks cost 1, clay costs 2, a sponge costs 3 and a straw drain costs 1. List what you will buy. Explain how your choices meet one criterion and stay inside the budget.
Now our team has a clear design brief. Next, we tackle the flooding part of the council’s problem and learn how one big city handles stormwater.
Exit ticket: write one criterion and one constraint for the council's plan. Label each one.
Materials: printed store price list, 10 paper point tokens per team, each team’s data tables from the investigations.
Setup: Post the store prices. Keep the point budget the same for every team so comparisons stay fair later.
Listen for: students who mix up criteria and constraints. Ask: “Is that a goal or a limit?” Also listen for criteria that cannot be measured.
Support / stretch: Offer a sentence frame: “Our design must ___ (criterion). It cannot ___ (constraint).” Stretch: add a third constraint, such as building time of 10 minutes.