
write a claim-evidence-reasoning argument about how a living thing’s inside and outside structures help it survive, and judge whether evidence is strong enough.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Look back at your data tables from the seed, celery, and feather labs. Circle the one observation that surprised you most. Share it with your team.
Which of these is an observation, not a guess?
Read like a scientist: every living thing is a system. A system is a group of parts that work together. Outside structures help a living thing meet its world. They help it find food, stay safe, and move. Inside structures keep it alive from within. They move water, blood, air, and food where they need to go.
Plants are systems too. Roots hold the plant in the ground and take in water. Tiny tubes inside the stem carry water up. Leaves make food from sunlight, air, and water. A seed coat protects the baby plant, and stored food feeds it. Our blue celery showed the water path with our own eyes.
Animals have outside parts like fur, feathers, claws, beaks, and eyes. Inside, the heart pumps blood. The lungs take in air. The stomach breaks down food. Bones hold the body up, and in birds many bones are hollow and light. The brain is the control center. No one part can keep the animal alive alone.
Worked example 1: a CER about black bears. Black bears live in many eastern forests. Here is how Priya built an argument.
Worked example 2: strong or weak evidence? Is Priya’s evidence strong? Yes. It names real structures and shows how each one helps. Now look at Diego’s first try: “Bears survive winter because they are big.” That is weak. It does not connect a part to a job. Strong evidence passes three checks: it names a real structure, it comes from an observation or a trusted source, and it connects to the claim.
CER sentence starters. Claim: “The ____ has structures that help it ____.” Evidence: “We observed that ____.” or “Our source says ____.” Reasoning: “This shows ____ because ____. These parts work together by ____.”
Work with your team. The Recorder writes, but everyone helps think. Use the arrows to move through the steps.
On your own, fix a weak argument.
Diego wrote: “Claim: Birds are good at flying. Evidence: Birds are cool.” Rewrite his CER using two real bird structures, one outside and one inside, and explain how they work together.
How confident are you that you can I can use evidence to explain how a living thing's parts help it survive.
Today you turned observations into a real argument. Next time we will build models of how senses, the brain, and actions work together.
Exit ticket: write one claim about a plant or animal. Give one piece of strong evidence and tell why it is strong.
Materials: students’ data tables from 3.03–3.08; a CER sentence-starter card per team; photos of a black bear.
Setup: Read the “every living thing is a system” section aloud or as partner reading. Model the bear CER together, then release teams. Collect team CERs as a formative check on 4-LS1-1.
Listen for: evidence that is opinion (“pretty,” “cool”) instead of structure and function; reasoning that just repeats the claim; and “bears sleep all winter without waking” (accept “rest in a den”).
Support / stretch: Provide a CER graphic organizer and allow oral CERs recorded by a partner. Stretch: ask students to add a second piece of evidence from a different structure and explain how the two work together.