
brainstorm at least three nature-inspired invention ideas, and check each one against the problem, the criteria, and the constraints.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Look at our Wonder Board. Put a check next to every question we can now answer. Which question is still open? Talk about it with your team.
Engineers borrowing a structure from nature to solve a human problem is called…
Read like an engineer: brainstorming rules. To ideate means to come up with many ideas. In a brainstorm, quantity comes first. Write every idea, even silly ones. Do not judge yet. Build on each other’s ideas with “Yes, and…” After the brainstorm, you check each idea against the problem, the criteria, and the constraints. That is when you choose.
Start from a structure. Look back at everything we studied. For each structure, ask: “What is its job in nature? What human problem needs that same job?” For example, burr hooks grab and hold, so they could hold things together. Quiet owl feathers soften sound, so they could make a machine quieter. Hollow, braced bird bones are light and strong, so they could help build something light. A chipmunk’s stretchy cheek pouches carry a lot in a small space, so they could inspire a stretchy bag.
Worked example 1: Priya’s idea web. Priya put “celery water tubes” in the middle. She drew three ideas around it: a straw system that waters a plant from a jar, a drip line for a school garden, and a tube that moves rainwater to a bucket. She checked them against the criteria. All three borrow a real structure. The garden drip line solves a real need at school. The jar waterer fits on a desk. She starred it.
Worked example 2: checking against constraints. Diego loved his idea for a full-size owl-feather fan for the gym. Then he checked the constraints. It would not fit on a desk, and it would cost too much. So he scaled it down to a hand fan with fringed paper edges. A good idea that breaks a constraint can often be changed to fit.
Remember why needs change. People’s needs and wants change over time. A good invention fits what people need now. Ask: “Would a nature center visitor today want this? Why?”
| Our idea | Structure we borrow (plant or animal) | Human problem it solves | Meets criteria? (yes / not yet) | Fits constraints? (yes / not yet) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Idea 1 | ||||
| Idea 2 | ||||
| Idea 3 | ||||
| Idea 4 |
Brainstorm with your team first, then check. The Reporter will share your team’s best idea. Use the arrows to move through the steps.
On your own, explain your thinking.
Pick the idea you like best. Explain how its structure does a job in nature, and how that same job could help people today.
Think back to the Then-and-Now table from lesson 3.02. How might people's wants for your invention change in the future?
You studied nature, made sense of it, and now you have ideas. In the next phase, your team will choose one idea and build it. Bring your idea table!
Exit ticket: write your top idea. Name one criterion it meets and one constraint you will have to watch.
Materials: chart paper and markers for idea webs; the idea table; the class criteria and constraints list from 3.08; the Wonder Board.
Setup: 8 minutes of silent individual idea writing, then 10 minutes of team “Yes, and…” building, then 10 minutes of checking against criteria and constraints. Save idea tables; the Build phase starts from them.
Listen for: ideas that only look like an animal (an “owl-shaped lamp”) instead of borrowing a structure’s function. Ask: “Which part does a job, and what job?” Also listen for teams that judge ideas during the brainstorm.
Support / stretch: Offer a structure–job card deck (burr hooks: grab; owl feathers: quiet; bird bones: light and strong; cheek pouches: carry). Stretch: combine two structures in one idea and explain why both are needed.