
build two different solutions that keep soil on a hill and water off the road, and share them with another team.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Look at your team’s brainstorm list from the Make Sense phase. Circle the idea your team thinks will work best. Be ready to say why.
Which will hold the most soil on a steep model hill?
Junior engineers, time to build! Engineers solve problems by trying more than one idea. Today each team builds at least two solutions on the pan model hill. Then we compare them.
Solution menu.
Worked example 1: cause and effect. Malik’s team knows that fast water carries more soil. So they build terraces from craft sticks. Each step slows the water. Slower water carries less soil. The cause they change is water speed. The effect they want is less erosion.
Worked example 2: two ideas, two jobs. Ava’s team builds a sponge “rain garden” at the bottom of one hill. On another hill, they build a craft-stick wall. The sponge soaks up water and keeps the “road” dry. The wall keeps more soil on the hill. Each idea solves a different part of the problem!
Peer critique. Visit another team’s build. Use three starters: “I like…” “I wonder…” “What if…” Be kind, be specific, be helpful.
Build two solutions on your model hill. Test each with the same slope (2 books) and the same cup of water. Record your results.
| Solution | Mud rating (1–5) | Did the “road” stay dry? | Cost (cheap / medium / high) | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| No solution (control) | — | |||
| Solution 1: | ||||
| Solution 2: |
Think like an engineer for the council.
Name your two solutions. For each one, explain how it protects people from mud or flooding. Use “because” in each answer.
Based on your test and the feedback you got, what is one change you will make to your best prototype?
You built prototypes and heard feedback, just like real engineers. Next, we look closely at what the council’s plan must do and what it can cost.
Exit ticket: which of your two solutions worked better? Use one number from your data table.
Materials (per team): the pan model hill, craft sticks, clay or play dough, small rocks or gravel, kitchen sponges cut into strips (rain garden), straws (drain pipes), grass clippings or pre-sprouted seed mats, cups of water, paper towels.
Setup: Lay out the solution materials as a “store.” Keep the control (bare hill) test so teams have something to compare.
Listen for: “a wall stops the rain.” A wall holds soil but does not remove water, so drainage still matters.
Support / stretch: Give struggling teams a two-item menu. Stretch: ask teams to combine two solutions and predict whether the combo beats each one alone.