
write a claim-evidence-reasoning explanation of how moving air masses changed our weather, and explain why forecasts are given as probabilities.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. A forecast says “40 percent chance of thunderstorms this afternoon.” Jamal says, “So it will rain for 40 percent of the afternoon.” Is he right? Decide with a partner.
What does a 40 percent chance of rain mean?
Reading: why weather changes. An air mass takes on the properties of the place where it forms. Air that sits over a cold northern land becomes cold and dry. Air over a warm ocean becomes warm and humid. Winds then carry these air masses across the continent. Where two air masses meet, a front forms. Denser cold air pushes under warmer air, and the warm air rises. Rising air cools, its water vapor condenses, and clouds and precipitation can form. After the front passes, the new air mass brings its own temperature and moisture. That is why the weather can change in just a few hours.
Reading: why forecasts are probabilities. Many things affect the weather at once: the speed of a front, the moisture in the air, hills and valleys, nearby lakes, and the heating of the ground that day. Small differences in any of these can change where a storm forms. So forecasters say how likely an event is, using patterns from many past days and computer models.
Worked example 1: a CER from our log. Here is Priya’s team’s explanation, built from the sample data in 4.04.
Worked example 2: judging our tools and methods. Diego’s team noticed gaps in their own log: no readings on weekends, and one day when the thermometer sat in the Sun. They filled the gaps with National Weather Service data and noted which numbers came from which source. Knowing how data were collected tells us how much to trust them.
Use the reading, our class log and the sample data.
Write your own CER. Use these sentence starters:
Pick one weather change from our own class log. Write a CER that explains it with air masses and fronts, and name the tools that collected your evidence.
Explain to a green team member why our station's forecast should say “likely” or give a percent instead of a promise.
We can now explain a storm with air masses and fronts, and we know why forecasts are probabilities. Next time we zoom out from one day to climate.
Exit ticket: explain how the movement of one air mass into another can turn a sunny morning into a stormy afternoon.
Materials: the class weather log, the 4.04 sample log, CER sentence starters on the board, a few printed forecast screenshots.
Setup: before class, find one day in the class log with a clear front passage. If none exists, use the sample log for the whole class.
Listen for: “forecasters are guessing” (they use data, patterns and models; probability is an honest measure of uncertainty). Evidence that only restates the claim; push for numbers.
Support / stretch: give a partly filled CER. Stretch: compare the class log with the NWS log and explain any mismatch.