
refine measurable criteria and constraints for the trail guide and brainstorm several guide ideas grounded in our science.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Reread the Wonder Board. Check every question we can now answer with evidence.
Pick one Wonder Board question. Answer it in two sentences using evidence from an investigation.
Trail geologists, time to ideate. To ideate means to generate many ideas before choosing. First we sharpen our criteria and constraints, so we can judge ideas fairly.
Class criteria (draft). The guide: (1) explains at least five trail stops; (2) covers the rock cycle, plate-motion evidence, slow and fast changes and the water cycle; (3) is scientifically accurate, checked against our evidence; (4) lets a visitor read each stop in under two minutes; (5) works for visitors about age 10 and up.
Class constraints (draft). It fits on one folded sheet or five small signs; it costs little to print; it survives rain if outdoors; it keeps visitors on the trail and tells them to leave rocks and fossils in place; we have a limited number of build days.
Worked example 1: weighing criteria with numbers. Ava’s team scores ideas from 0 to 3 on each criterion. An audio tour scores 3 on accuracy but 1 on cost, because phones and signal are not reliable on every trail. The scores make trade-offs visible.
Worked example 2: the cost of doing nothing. Malik asks what happens if there is no guide at all. Visitors stay confused, some may dig fossils out or leave the trail to search, and bare, trampled slopes erode faster. Not solving the problem also affects the environment.
Brainstorm rules. Go for quantity, build on others’ ideas, then check every idea against the criteria and constraints. Choosing and building the best design comes in the next phase.
Brainstorm at least four guide ideas. Score each from 0 (does not meet) to 3 (fully meets).
| Guide idea | Science it uses | Five stops? | Accurate? | Readable in 2 min per stop? | Low cost? | Protects the trail? | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Choose and defend an idea.
Pick the idea you think is strongest. Explain which criteria it meets best, which constraint makes it hardest, and one way it could affect the environment, good or bad.
Our ideas are ready to compare and build. Next: your 3DX field trip, When Continents Fit Together. Then the Build phase begins.
How confident are you that you can I can define criteria and constraints and use them to judge ideas.
Exit ticket: name your best guide idea, one criterion it meets and one constraint it must fit.
Materials: the class criteria and constraints chart from 3.09, sticky notes, chart paper, all notebook data, the Wonder Board.
Timing (50 min): Do Now 5, refine criteria 10, brainstorm 12, scoring and guided questions 13, independent and exit 10.
Listen for: criteria and constraints mixed up. Quick test: “Does it say what the guide DOES, or what LIMITS it?” The scoring table and final open question are formative checks of MS-ETS1-1:1a, 2a, 3a and 3b. Save choosing among designs (MS-ETS1-2) for part 2.
Support / stretch: Offer an idea bank (folded brochure, numbered trail posts with a booklet, QR-code audio, a scaled deep-time walk with markers). Stretch: weight criteria by importance and recalculate totals.