
use a weighted decision matrix to evaluate competing trail-guide formats and make an evidence-based claim about the best one.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Two phones cost the same. One has a better camera; the other has a longer battery. How would YOU decide? Is a camera worth as much as battery life to everyone?
If one criterion matters twice as much as another, what should happen to its score?
Trail designers, today you become fair judges. A decision matrix is a table that scores each design against each criterion. It turns “I like this one” into a claim backed by evidence.
How it works. 1. List the criteria and constraints down the side. 2. Give each a weight from 1 to 3, so the most important ones count more. 3. Score each design 1 (poor) to 3 (strong) on each row. 4. Multiply score by weight. 5. Add each column. The highest total is the strongest design, unless it breaks a must-have constraint.
Worked example 1: the matrix. Priya’s team agreed accurate science matters most (weight 3). Accessibility and cost each get weight 2. Weatherproof gets weight 1.
| Criterion (weight) | Signs | QR audio | Field guide | Model |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Accurate, clear science (×3) | 2 → 6 | 3 → 9 | 3 → 9 | 3 → 9 |
| Accessible to many visitors (×2) | 2 → 4 | 3 → 6 | 2 → 4 | 2 → 4 |
| Fits the budget (×2) | 1 → 2 | 3 → 6 | 2 → 4 | 2 → 4 |
| Survives weather (×1) | 3 → 3 | 2 → 2 | 1 → 1 | 3 → 3 |
| Total | 15 | 23 | 18 | 20 |
These are sample scores. QR audio wins on paper with 23 points.
Worked example 2: check the evidence. Then Malik asked, “What if there is no cell signal on the trail?” The park staff confirmed signal is weak at two stops. That is new evidence. The team changed “accessible” for QR from 3 to 1 at those stops. They decided on a hybrid: a small sign at each stop, with a QR code for the full audio story. Combining strengths is a smart engineering move.
Make your claim. A strong claim names the winner, cites the totals, and admits the biggest weakness: “We chose ___ because it scored ___, mainly on ___. Its weakness is ___, so we will ___.”
Build your team’s matrix. First agree on weights; that is a team decision.
| Criterion | Weight | Signs | QR audio | Field guide | Model |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Accurate, clear science | |||||
| Understood in about 3 minutes | |||||
| Accessible to many visitors | |||||
| Fits the budget | |||||
| No harm to the park; survives weather | |||||
| Total |
Write your team’s design claim on your own.
Write a claim about which format (or hybrid) your team will build. Cite your matrix totals as evidence. Explain one strength and one weakness, and how you will handle the weakness.
Your format is chosen. Starting next lesson, you will prototype the stops themselves, one big science idea at a time.
Exit ticket: how is a decision matrix more fair than a class vote? Give one reason.
How confident are you that you can I can use a decision matrix to compare solutions and make a claim about the best one.
Materials: blank matrix tables, calculators optional, sticky notes for scores, the four-format sketches from 3.15.
Setup: if you can, check the real cell signal at your partner park or ask the staff, and share the answer as new evidence. Teams can choose a hybrid. The class does not need to pick one format; teams may build different ones, which makes 3.24’s visitor test richer.
Listen for: weights changed after scoring; adding scores without multiplying by weights; a winner chosen even though it breaks a constraint.
Support / stretch: provide a partly filled matrix. Stretch: recalculate with different weights and report whether the winner changes. That is a sensitivity check.